Butch studied him a long moment, then turned toward his horse.
“Then come Saturday and watch a man die over a question you won’t answer even to yourself.”
He rode away, not knowing which way it would fall. Rowan stood in his doorway long after the hoofbeats faded, the shotgun still in his hands, saying nothing to the dark behind him. Butch rode on, afraid he’d said too little, or nothing that would matter at all. 10 minutes later, inside the ranch house, Jacob Rowan sat down at his stepfather’s old writing desk and opened a drawer he hadn’t touched in years. It held two things.
The first placed there the week of Pike’s funeral was a brittle yellowed clipping from a Montana newspaper. Its headline describing the shooting in words that made Pike sound like a martyred lawman instead of a man with a violent reputation of his own. The second added two years later when Jacob went through his mother’s belongings after her death was a sealed letter in her handwriting that he’d never managed to open. He opened it that night for the first time. It wasn’t the letter he expected.
She wrote about the early years. Pike coming home some evenings with peppermint candy for a boy who wasn’t his by blood, filling the cabin with laughter, teaching Jacob to ride before he turned seven. But she wrote just as plainly about the man the rest of Landusky had learned to fear, the drinking that worsened with every year, the brawls that spilled out of saloons into the street, the badge Pike wore when it suited his temper and tossed aside when it didn’t, and the prisoner he’d beaten while holding him on a charge that was later dismissed. A beating no local authority ever charged him for. She had loved the man who raised Jacob, she wrote.
That was true and always would be, but love didn’t make every hard thing people said about him a lie. And she had decided long ago that Jacob deserved to know the whole of him, not only the parts easiest to bear. Her last line, underlined twice, was the one Jacob read three separate times before he could set the page down. “Do not spend your life making another man pay, just so you can remember only the best of your father.” Jacob rode out before first light on Saturday, alone, telling no one at the ranch where he was headed. Saddling his horse in the gray dark, he didn’t yet know whether he was riding to watch Denning finish what he’d paid for or to stop it.
He only knew he couldn’t sit at that writing desk any longer without an answer. Saturday morning, Larksburg Junction woke to the humming hush of a town that had heard through every channel gossip travels that something was going to happen on its main street at noon. Sheriff Dugan had spent two days listening to 11 frightened versions of what happened in the stable yard without receiving a single signed complaint. Nobody in town would put their name to a statement against a man who slapped old farmers for sport and smiled while he did it.