At eleven o’clock on a winter night in 1810, the west wing of Ashcombe House had gone quiet, but Diana could still hear the servants moving beyond the bedroom door. She was twenty-four, slight and pale from weeks of worry, with black hair loosened from its pins and a white gown twisted at the waist. Eric, the thirty-five-year-old Duke of Ashcombe, stood over her, his handsome face tight with anger. “You will stop speaking of leaving,” he said. “You are my wife.” Diana pushed against his chest and managed to force him away. “Being your wife does not give you the right to frighten me.” Eric caught her wrist. She pulled free, knocking a glass from the bedside table. It shattered against the rug. He seized her again, dragged her toward him,
and struck her across the face. The sound carried into the corridor. Outside, Gordon Ashcombe stopped with one hand on the doorframe. He was thirty, two years older than Diana had been when he first loved her, and he knew her voice better than he knew his own. For one terrible moment he could not move. “Gordon,” Diana cried. “Please, save me. Get me out of this cruel house.” Gordon’s fist closed until his knuckles whitened. He wanted to break the door down. He wanted to pull his brother away and take Diana somewhere no one could touch her. But he also knew Eric controlled the household, the servants, and the family guards. Then Gordon turned and ran down the corridor. Inside, Eric mistook the retreating footsteps for obedience. He told Diana that nobody in Ashcombe House would choose her over him.
She stared at the door, still hoping the man she had called would return. A moment later, the outer door burst open. He fetched their mother.
—
Beatrice entered without hurrying. She wore a dark silk dressing gown over her evening clothes, and her silver hair was pinned so firmly that not a strand had moved. Two footmen followed her. Gordon came behind them, breathing hard, his face flushed from the run. “Mother, you must see what he has done,” he began. Beatrice lifted one gloved finger. Gordon fell silent. She crossed the room, looked at Diana’s cheek, then at Eric. For a heartbeat, Diana thought the older woman might finally show concern. Instead, Beatrice turned and struck Diana across the face. “You will not turn my sons against one another,
” she said. Gordon stepped forward. “She called for help. I heard him strike her.” “You heard a private quarrel,” Beatrice replied. “And you will remember that this is your brother’s household.” Eric straightened his coat. The anger in his face softened into satisfaction. He had expected his mother to restore order, and she had done so in the way he preferred: by making Diana the problem. Beatrice ordered the footmen to take Gordon downstairs. She instructed a maid to remain outside Diana’s room and forbade anyone from bringing letters or visitors without her permission. Then she told Eric that the family would discuss the matter in the morning. Diana stood beside the bed, one hand against her cheek. “You know he is hurting me,” she said. Beatrice’s expression did not change.
“I know that a duchess must learn what her position requires.” When the others left, Diana heard the key turn from the outside. She had been locked in her own bedroom. Downstairs, Gordon demanded to know why their mother had protected Eric. Beatrice answered that a family could survive an unhappy marriage, but it could not survive a public scandal. Diana heard the key turn.
