“Do not touch me, Frederick. I have told you no.”

Elias stopped outside his brother’s bedchamber. At Briarcliffe Abbey, servants had learned to pass that door without listening. Tonight the old house was so quiet that Catherine’s frightened voice traveled beneath it. Rain struck the windows again.

“You are my wife,” Frederick answered. “You will give this family a son. I will not be made a fool before my father.”

A chair scraped. Catherine cried out for him to release her wrist. Elias struck the door with his shoulder before he had decided to move. The lock gave way, and he found his older brother standing over Catherine beside the bed. Her sleeve was torn at the cuff. She was trying to pull free.

“Take your hands off her,” Elias said.

Frederick turned, flushed and furious. “Get out of my chamber.”

“She asked you to stop.”

“This is a matter between husband and wife.”

Elias crossed the carpet, placed himself between them, and held out a hand to Catherine. She stepped behind him. He remembered that same hand holding his in the orchard three summers earlier, before the letters stopped and she became the wife of his brother.

Frederick seized Elias by the collar. Both men collided with the dressing table. A porcelain basin shattered. The noise brought footsteps along the corridor, then a maid’s horrified gasp.

Catherine did not reach for either man. She made for the open doorway while they struggled. At the threshold she turned, pale beneath her dark hair.

“Tell them the truth,” she said. “I have been telling you for months.”

Frederick froze. Elias released his coat. Behind the servants stood their mother, the Duchess of Briarcliffe, holding a candle. Her gaze settled first on Catherine, then on the broken door.

“What truth?” she demanded.

—

The duchess ordered everyone into the blue drawing room. Her proud eldest son came down with blood on his lip. Elias followed without speaking. Catherine appeared last, wrapped in a shawl supplied by Nora, her maid.

Their father, Duke Alistair, had been awakened. He sat beside the fireplace with a blanket over his knees. His gaze traveled from Frederick’s swollen cheek to Catherine’s shaking fingers.

“Who broke the door?” he asked.

“I did,” Elias said. “I heard her begging him to stop.”

“He has been lurking outside my wife’s room,” Frederick snapped. “Ask why.”

The duchess turned to Catherine. “You have embarrassed us quite sufficiently. There is no need to encourage these accusations.”

Catherine lifted her chin. “I was afraid. That is why he heard me.”

Frederick laughed without humor. “Tell them why he cared so much. Tell them what you were before you became my wife.”

Elias felt the room narrow. He had promised Catherine once that he would never use their history to injure her. Now silence would let Frederick turn that promise into a weapon.