“This may become public,” Lady Harrow warned gently.

“It already happened in private,” Catherine said. “That did not make it less real.”

As Nora prepared breakfast, a messenger arrived from Briarcliffe with two envelopes. One held a demand from Frederick that Catherine return immediately. The other contained a single sentence written in the duke’s hand: Do not come back until you feel safe. Beneath it lay the key to a small cottage on her mother’s former land.

—

By breakfast, Briarcliffe’s corridors were full of whispers. A housemaid had heard Frederick call Catherine faithless. Nobody agreed about what had happened afterward, but everyone knew that Catherine had left before daylight and had not taken her husband’s carriage.

Elias asked Fenwick, the family solicitor, to meet him in the library, where the curtains had not yet been opened and the grate remained cold.

“I will not ask you to defend me,” Elias said. “I need to know whether Catherine can remain away from her husband without being dragged back.”

Fenwick explained that marital law gave a wife painfully limited remedies. A formal separation based on cruelty might be pursued through ecclesiastical proceedings, but Catherine would need evidence, witnesses, money, and a willingness to endure public scrutiny. A private separation agreement with secure maintenance could protect her sooner if Frederick consented.

“He will never consent,” Elias said.

“Then the family must cease making his consent the only thing that matters.”

Elias also showed Fenwick the letter supposedly sent by Catherine. He had kept it in a locked desk, though he hated himself for doing so. Fenwick inspected its seal and held the sheet toward the light. A watermark belonged to Briarcliffe’s household stationery, not the paper Catherine had ordinarily used.

“Someone here prepared this,” the solicitor murmured.

Elias thought of his mother’s calm announcement of Catherine’s engagement. He remembered his own refusal to ask questions, his pride wounded too deeply to risk hearing the truth.

When he returned to the hall, Frederick was waiting beneath the staircase.

“You can have her reputation,” his brother said. “I shall keep the estate.”

Elias looked at the other man’s bruised mouth. “You are speaking as though those things belonged to you.”

Frederick smiled. “Ask Father about Moorfield before you decide what I own.”

—

Catherine spent the next morning sorting through the few possessions Nora had brought from Briarcliffe. Inside her treasured silver locket lay a dried violet Elias had given her beside the pear tree.

Lady Harrow knocked before entering. She brought Mr. Wetherell, a solicitor with an unremarkable coat and steady manner. Catherine told him everything she had told her hostess, including the part that might invite gossip.

“I cared for Lord Elias before my marriage,” she said. “I never met him privately afterward. I did not betray my vows.”