Fenwick also obtained the original letters patent granting Alistair’s grandfather the dukedom, to descend through legitimate male descendants. He studied the wording carefully. Frederick’s birth before his parents’ marriage could not be corrected merely by the later wedding. It raised a serious legal obstacle to his claimed place as heir.

Elias felt no triumph. He remembered Frederick teaching him to swim and riding together as boys. That brother had existed alongside the man who frightened Catherine. Love did not require Elias to deny either memory.

That evening Fenwick reported to Duke Alistair. He laid the documents across the desk but advised obtaining counsel’s formal opinion before notifying the wider family. Alistair looked at the early marriage pedigree he had signed himself.

“I made my sons compete for a place I knew was falsely described,” he whispered.

—

Frederick invited three influential cousins to Briarcliffe without his father’s permission. He told them Catherine had manipulated Elias and that the birth records were being used to punish him for an unhappy marriage. The cousins arrived predisposed to believe him, carrying old assumptions about marriage.

Elias refused to attend their private supper. He would not argue Catherine’s conduct before men who had never asked for her account. Duke Alistair, however, entered the dining room and asked whether his son had invited the guests to assist an investigation or merely to prevent one.

Frederick accused his father of dishonoring their name. Alistair answered that the dishonor began when he signed a pedigree he knew to be inaccurate. The cousins exchanged uneasy looks. For the first time, the duke accepted responsibility without handing it to his wife or sons.

Frederick then turned to Catherine’s absence. “Would a respectable wife leave her husband’s house and receive letters from another man?”

“She left because she was frightened,” Alistair said. “And if you insist on discussing letters, we may discuss who kept them from reaching their recipients.”

One cousin, Lady Margaret, requested that Catherine be heard in her own words. The duke sent a copy of the invitation to Wetherell, who asked Catherine whether she wished to participate. She declined a dinner table confrontation but agreed that her sworn account could be read by a solicitor to those with a legitimate interest.

The cousins received the statement the next morning. It described Frederick’s repeated demands, her refusal, the broken door, and the threats against her sister’s family. They also received Nora’s independent account. One cousin returned home immediately. Another wrote to the duke requesting a formal family council.

Frederick read the letter and realized the story he had told no longer belonged exclusively to him.

—

The retired secretary, Mrs. Bell, arrived from Bath in a plain hired coach, carrying a ledger tied with blue ribbon and a bundle of letters. She was a remarkably quiet woman who had once believed that serving a duchess meant carrying out instructions without question.