When the meeting ended, Alistair asked Elias what sort of duke he intended to be when his time came. Elias looked at the repaired bedroom door at the end of the hall. The hinges had been replaced, but a pale mark remained in the wood.
“One whose doors can be opened from the inside,” he answered.
For the first time in months, his father did not argue with him.
—
Catherine moved into the cottage her late mother had loved, a low stone house with a pear tree leaning above the garden wall. Lady Harrow visited twice a week. Nora chose to remain as her companion. Catherine began slowly restoring the neglected garden and managing the small funds now under her own trustees.
She also helped her sister’s family negotiate the threatened debt without asking Elias or the duke to pay it. The creditor accepted a structured agreement after Wetherell uncovered errors in the account.
Elias did not visit until she invited him. He arrived one April afternoon without a crest on his carriage door, carrying a packet of violets wrapped in plain paper. Catherine met him outside, where the gate stood open and the path smelled of wet earth.
“I heard you were named heir,” she said.
“It is a grave duty, not a prize.”
“Then perhaps you will manage it honestly.”
He smiled sadly. “I intend to try.”
They walked slowly together beside the familiar pear tree and spoke of ordinary things first: Nora’s new puppy, Lady Harrow’s terrible card playing, the tenant school Catherine hoped to support. Only when the light began to fade did Elias mention the letters.
“I believed you had left me,” he said.
“I believed the same of you.”
He asked whether she wished they had discovered the truth earlier. Catherine considered the years neither could reclaim. “Every day,” she answered. “But I do not wish to become somebody who lives only in those years.”
Elias offered his hand. She took it, not as a promise of marriage, but because she chose the comfort. Above them the pear branches moved in the wind. The family would remember the night its heir changed. Catherine would remember the night somebody listened when she said no.