Frederick turned toward the door. At the threshold he asked whether Catherine might ever forgive him.

“That is for her to decide,” Alistair answered. “And forgiveness would not restore your right to command her.”

After Frederick left, Elias stood beside his father in silence. Alistair admitted that he had been weak when strength mattered. Elias did not offer easy comfort. He asked only that the duke put the succession correction in writing and protect Catherine’s agreement regardless of how the family wished the story to end.

—

The legal opinion arrived under a red wax seal. Fenwick read it to the duke, Elias, and two witnesses in the study. Counsel had examined the patent, the parish registers, the marriage record, and testimony. On those documents, Frederick was not the duke’s legitimate eldest son for purposes of the hereditary title. Elias stood next in the lawful line.

Fenwick stressed that the proper authorities would need accurate records and that a peerage was not a possession the duke could rearrange merely because he preferred one son. The duke ordered his family’s pedigree corrected and instructed Fenwick to lodge the evidence through the appropriate channels.

Separate property settlements could be revised where the duke retained lawful power. He removed Frederick from estate management, appointed independent trustees, and made provision for Elias to assume responsibility as the recognized heir. The income that belonged to other beneficiaries would remain protected.

Catherine learned the result from Wetherell, not from Elias. Wetherell explained the distinction between the title and the family’s negotiable property arrangements. She listened without delight.

“If Elias becomes duke, people will say I put him there,” she observed.

“The dates were written before you were born,” Wetherell replied. “Your courage caused questions to be asked, but you did not create the answers.”

At Briarcliffe, Helena wept when the amended pedigree was placed before her. She asked Alistair whether he would preserve Frederick’s public dignity. He replied that he would defend his son’s humanity but would not continue a false record.

Then he asked her to account for the stolen correspondence. She admitted directing its concealment. Alistair instructed that Catherine receive copies and the right to decide whether any part became public.

When Elias learned what his mother had said, he asked only one question: “Did Catherine hear an apology from her?”

—

The duchess’s apology arrived as a letter addressed to Lady Catherine, carried without a family seal. It acknowledged withholding correspondence and arranging pressure through debts. It also complained that Helena herself had endured cruel judgments in youth. Catherine read the pages carefully and did not allow their sorrowful tone to conceal their purpose.

“She wants me to understand her,” Catherine told Lady Harrow. “She has not yet said she understands what she did to me.”