“Catherine and I intended to marry,” he said. “Before I was sent away. Before both of us were told the other had changed their mind.”

The duchess set her candle down too sharply. Wax splashed the table.

“You hear him? He admits it. My own brother wanted my wife.”

“Before she was your wife,” Catherine said. “And wanting someone does not give you the right to frighten her.”

A rustle came from the doorway. The elderly housekeeper, Mrs. Beckett, had arrived despite having been dismissed from the Abbey the previous spring. She held a folded paper in her trembling hand.

“Your Grace,” she told the duke, “there is something about your eldest son’s place in this family that you must finally hear.”

—

“This is not the hour for old servants’ stories,” the duchess said.

Mrs. Beckett did not retreat this time. The weary duke raised one unsteady hand, asking his wife to wait.

“How did you enter?” he asked.

“Nora sent word that Lady Catherine might need a witness. I came because I once kept silent when another woman asked me for help.”

Frederick snatched at the paper, but Beckett moved it behind her back. Elias stepped between them. The duke requested that the servants remain. It was the first time he had allowed his household to hear a family quarrel without ordering the doors closed.

“Speak plainly,” he said.

“Not tonight,” Beckett replied. “Not while Lady Catherine is expected to answer for the conduct of men around her. First let her leave safely.”

Catherine silently stared at the housekeeper. At her wedding Beckett had been the only person who asked whether she had chosen this marriage freely. Catherine had not dared answer.

The duchess insisted her daughter in law remain beneath her husband’s roof. Elias argued that Nora could escort Catherine to the widow Lady Harrow’s house five miles away. Frederick objected. The duke finally spoke with the authority he seldom exercised now.

“Catherine will decide where she sleeps.”

“I will go to Lady Harrow,” she said. “And I will not return tomorrow simply because you order it.”

Elias offered to summon a carriage but did not presume to accompany her. Catherine asked Nora to travel with her instead. That small choice drew another angry look from Frederick.

When the women departed, Beckett placed her folded note before the duke. Inside was a name, the village of Moorfield, and two dates that stood a year apart. He read them, went pale, and whispered one sentence.

“I thought that record was gone.”

—

Three summers earlier, Elias had believed the hardest part of loving Catherine Vale would be asking her father for permission. Elias had always loved her laugh before he ever dared touch her hand.