On the road home, Elias broke the silence.

“Does Frederick know?”

“Someone has certainly given him reason to suspect,” Fenwick answered. “And that makes his desperation for a son more troubling, not less.”

—

At dusk Frederick rode to Lady Harrow’s gate, dressed as though he were paying a courteous call. She refused him entry and told the gardener to stand by the gate. From the lane he called Catherine’s name and claimed he had come to apologize. Catherine listened from the drawing room, remembering how apologies at Briarcliffe always came with demands.

“If he has something to say, he may write to my solicitor,” she told the footman.

Frederick heard the answer and laughed. When his horse finally turned toward home, Lady Harrow sent a stable boy to note the direction and time.

Meanwhile, the duke summoned his wife to his study. Their sons were not present. He placed the two Moorfield dates between them and asked whether the register had ever been amended.

Helena stood very still. “We did what was necessary to spare the family shame.”

“We lied,” Alistair said.

She answered that Frederick had grown up as the heir, trained for the role, praised by every visitor, and promised responsibility for the great estate. Telling him now that the pedigree was false would destroy him.

“You cannot repair one injustice by forcing a woman to bear him a child,” he said.

Helena’s composure cracked. She insisted she had never ordered Frederick’s behavior. Alistair believed that part, but he also remembered the letters she had controlled and the debts Frederick had used to secure Catherine’s marriage.

“You knew they loved each other,” he said.

“I knew Elias would never fight for the title.”

That answer frightened him more than an admission of spite. Helena had arranged two lives around the question of inheritance and called the arrangement duty.

Beyond the study door Frederick waited unseen. He had heard enough to understand that the secret he feared was no longer his alone.

—

The winter gathering at Briarcliffe had been planned months earlier. The duchess stubbornly insisted it proceed, hoping another ordinary ceremony might silence extraordinary rumors. But the news of the broken bedroom door had reached the village before the first carriage arrived.

Catherine did not attend. Lady Harrow represented her at the subscriptions table and calmly refused to explain the young woman’s absence to people seeking entertainment. Elias remained quietly near his father, who looked exhausted but determined to finish the morning.

Frederick entered late and spoke loudly enough to be heard beyond the table. “My wife has left my house for my brother’s protection. You may decide for yourselves what that signifies.”

The room went still. Elias stepped forward, but the duke caught his sleeve.