“Can you make a man eat who has decided not to?”

The question came from behind her, low and level, pitched under the noise of the fair, so that it reached her and nobody else. Sarah Quillgrove did not turn at once. She stood where she had stood since first light at the end of the row of cooks below the market cross in Devizes. A wooden basting spoon was pushed through her apron string, so that every farmer’s wife who passed could see what she was for. Further down the street, the carters wore a twist of whipcord in their hats.

The dairy maids held milking stools. The shepherds, down off the plain in their long smocks, each wore a tuft of gray wool pinned above the brim. The air smelled of trampled straw, roast goose, and the first mist burning off the chalk. It was Michaelmas morning.

Half of Wiltshire was looking for a new place, and the other half was looking for someone to fill it. She knew the voice. That was why she did not turn. She had not heard it for 4 years, and she had told herself in that time that she had forgotten it, and her own body was now calling her a liar.

Her hand had closed on the handle of the spoon. Her heart had begun to knock against her stays like someone at a locked door. She made herself breathe out. Then she turned round slowly, the way she would turn a full pan off the fire, and looked up.

He was taller than she remembered, or perhaps only straighter. The coat was dark blue and very well cut, and it sat on him the way a uniform had once sat on him, as if he was still waiting to be inspected. His hair was dark, cropped short, with gray come early at the temples. There was a thin white scar along his jaw that had not been there before.

The eyes were the same. They were a warm chestnut brown, and they were the only warm thing about him. Behind him, the crowd had drawn back a little, the way a crowd does round a man it has been told to be careful of. And she heard the whisper go along the row of cooks like wind through barley.

“The Duke. That’s him. The shepherd’s boy. Castlewick.”

“Your Grace,” Sarah said, and dipped a curtsy that was exactly as deep as it needed to be.

“Miss Quillgrove.”

He did not smile. He had never smiled easily, even when he was a lieutenant with his arm in a sling and nothing in the world to lose.

“You have not answered me.”

She looked at him a moment longer. Then she answered him honestly, because she had never learned to do anything else with a question about food.

“Not by coaxing,” she said. “Coaxing only tells a man he’s being watched. If he has made up his mind not to eat, every spoon you hold out to him is a battle, and he will win every one of them. You have to make the food matter less than the room. You cook as if he were not there. You eat your own dinner in front of him and talk about something else. And you wait.”