She Ordered Him to Apologize—Not Knowing He Had Come to Choose a Wife

Whoever you are, you will apologize to her this minute, or I will not allow your beast to drink from the stream. The man looked down at Sarah Lamb from the height of that enormous horse, his breath white in the early winter air, as though she was something that had wandered out of the hedgerow, and for a long moment he did not answer at all. Sarah did not lower her hand. Her heart was still pounding from the sound of Mary Beth’s scream in the trees, and the girl was pressed against her back now, soaked to the knees and shaking beneath her woolen cloak. Her fingers knotted in Sarah’s heavy winter skirts.

The basket lay overturned on the frost-whitened grass where Sarah had dropped it, and the afternoon’s late rosehips lay scattered and trodden, and she did not care in the least. “You will prevent my horse,” he said at last, very slowly, “from drinking from my own river.” His own river. Thin ice fringed the banks, but the shallow current still ran freely over the gravel. Sarah had been wading in that water since she was smaller than Mary Beth, and in all those years, she had never heard a single soul lay claim to it. Who in heaven’s name did he think he was?

“I do not care whose river it is,” she said. “You came through those trees as though you were leading a cavalry charge, and you very nearly ran her down. The least a gentleman could do is say that he is sorry.” “And the least a lady could do,” he returned, “is refrain from standing in a man’s path and shouting at him. You are behaving, madam, as if the apology were owed to you.” Sarah felt the heat climb into her face. She had been called headstrong by her mother more times than she could count, and far too clever for her own good by more than one disappointed gentleman, but she did not think anyone had ever spoken to her with such cool contempt.

But he was no longer looking at her. His gaze had moved past her shoulder to Mary Beth, and something in his face changed. It was small, a loosening at the jaw, gone almost before it came, but Sarah saw it, and it unsettled her more than all his rudeness. “What is your name?” he asked the girl. Sarah’s hand found Mary Beth’s shoulder and pressed it in warning, but Mary Beth was 12 years old, and had never in her life been able to resist a question.

“Mary Beth, sir.” He inclined his head to her, and it was a true bow, the kind of gentleman gives a lady across a ballroom floor. Then I beg your pardon, Miss Mary Beth. It was badly done of me to frighten you, and I am sorry for it. Mary Beth’s face broke into a smile. Sarah’s did not.

He turned to her last of all and touched the brim of his hat. Madam. Nothing more. No name and no apology for her. He gathered his reins and rode up out of the water onto her father’s land as if that belonged to him, too.

A second rider had come out of the trees behind him, an older gentleman, and as he passed, he looked down at Sarah with an expression she could not mistake. It was the look of a man who has just watched someone put her hand into a lion’s mouth and cannot believe she still has it. Sarah lifted her chin and held his gaze until he had gone by. “Aunt Sarah.” Mary Beth was tugging at her sleeve. “I have seen him before.” “Seen whom?” “That gentleman.” Mary Beth was frowning after him.