Several drawers held only folded clothes that were too small. In the closet, on the top shelf, he found a shoebox filled with crackers, raisins, two apples, and a crumpled dinner roll wrapped in a napkin. Naomi stared at the floor.

“I save things,” she whispered.

Timothy set the shoebox down with shaking hands. Then he heard Elena at the bedroom door, and he knew this was only the beginning. Timothy turned slowly, forcing himself not to shout the second he saw Elena leaning against the doorframe as though all of this could still be explained away.

“What is that?”

he asked, pointing to the shoebox. Elena glanced at it and shrugged.

“She’s sneaky with food.

I’ve been trying to correct it.”

Naomi moved closer to Timothy’s leg.

“You call a six-year-old sneaky because she hides crackers in her closet?”

Elena blew out a breath.

“Timothy, please.

You’re fresh off a return, you’re emotional, and she’s feeding off it.

Children hoard when they’ve been indulged.”

Indulged. The word almost made him laugh. He knelt beside Naomi.

“Go wash your face, baby.

Then bring your favorite book downstairs.

We’ll read together.”

She hesitated.

“Will I get in trouble?”

“No.”

He looked straight at her.

“Not for telling the truth.”

When she slipped into the bathroom, Timothy stood. The house felt smaller than it ever had before. The walls held family photos from the last three years—beach trips, pumpkin patches, school recitals. He suddenly saw what he had missed. Naomi was often at the edge of the frame, standing slightly apart. Elena and the twins occupied the center.

“You need to tell me everything,” he said.

Elena crossed her arms tighter.

“Everything?

Fine. Your daughter is difficult. She whines, refuses food, clings to you, and acts helpless whenever she doesn’t get her way.

I have been carrying this household alone while you play hero somewhere else.”

The words hit, but Timothy refused to lose the thread.

“So you fed her old pizza on the floor?”

“It wasn’t like that.”

“It looked exactly like that.”

Elena opened her mouth, then closed it. Timothy stepped toward the dresser and pulled out another drawer. At the back lay three lunch notes from Naomi’s school, two unopened and one crumpled. Low balance. Missed payment. Contact office. He held them up.

“Why was her lunch account empty?”

“I forgot to reload it.”

“Three times?”

The silence that followed was uglier than an argument. He remembered wiring money every month. He remembered Elena assuring him by phone that the kids were good, the house was fine, Naomi loved school, everything was under control. He began to wonder how many calls he had missed while believing everything was fine.