She’s telling everyone. Telling everyone what? The truth. She got him fired. Uh, his wife got him fired and now he’s blaming me and I don’t know what to do.

I sat up in Pete’s guest bed, suddenly wide awake. Sandra got Greg fired. She sent all those pictures to HR, to his boss, to everyone in the company. They terminated him for having an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate. They’re investigating me, too.

Wow, that’s terrible. Brian, please. I made a mistake, but I don’t deserve this. My whole life is falling apart. Your whole life fell apart the moment you decided to cheat on me.

Everything else is just consequences. I never meant for it to go this far. What did you think would happen, Melissa? That I’d just accept it? That his wife wouldn’t find out?

That there wouldn’t be any consequences? She was quiet for a moment, sniffling. I thought I thought you’d fight for me. The words hit me like a slap. After everything, the lies, the cheating, the humiliation.

She’d expected me to compete for her attention like some lovesick teenager. “Fight for you?” I laughed, and it came out bitter and cold. Why would I fight for someone who didn’t want to be kept? That’s not fair. You know what’s not fair?

20 years of marriage thrown away for some middle-aged man with a midlife crisis and a company credit card. Greg loves me. Greg loved the idea of you now that it’s costing him his job and his marriage. Let’s see how much he loves you. I hung up and turned off the phone.

Pete was making coffee in the kitchen already dressed for work. Rough night? He asked. Getting better by the minute. That afternoon, Janet called with an update.

Melissa’s attorney wants to meet. She’s ready to settle already. Apparently, she’s facing some professional difficulties. Her employer is conducting an investigation into her relationship with a former supervisor. She wants to resolve the divorce quickly and quietly.

What are they offering? Everything you asked for. Plus, she’ll sign a non-disclosure agreement about the divorce proceedings. I thought about that. Melissa was trying to control the narrative.

Keep the details of her affair from becoming public record. It was a reasonable request except for one problem. Counter offer, I said. I’ll sign the NDA after she makes a public apology. What kind of public apology?

The kind that explains to everyone who witnessed our Valentine’s dinner exactly what happened and why. Janet was quiet for a moment. That’s unusual. So was having dinner with my wife and her boyfriend. I’ll make the call.

The meeting was set for Thursday at Janet’s office. Melissa arrived with Richard Blackwood, her attorney, looking like she hadn’t slept in days. Her hair was pulled back in a messy ponytail. Her clothes were wrinkled, and she had dark circles under her eyes. “Brian,” she said when she saw me.

“Thank you for agreeing to meet.” I nodded, but didn’t speak. Janet had advised me to let the lawyers do the talking. “My client is prepared to accept your terms,” Blackwood said, “with one modification. The public apology would be limited to a written statement, not a verbal admission. No, Janet replied.

My client was very specific. A public verbal apology to everyone who witnessed the incident at Marello’s restaurant. That’s unreasonable. What’s unreasonable is bringing your boyfriend to your Valentine’s dinner with your husband. Melissa finally spoke up.