Mrs. Parker opened her front door before Marcus could knock twice. She
was a retired school librarian who lived next door and had often watched
the children when Marcus and Laura needed help. When she saw Elijah in
his father’s jacket, she immediately brought him inside and found a dry
sweatshirt.

“Would you like some warm cocoa?” she asked.

Elijah nodded. Marcus knelt beside him.

“I’ll be right next door.

I need to make sure everyone is safe.” “Don’t leave me with her,” Elijah
whispered.

“I won’t.” The boy’s fingers tightened around his father’s sleeve.

Marcus felt the small grip and understood that this was not simply a
reaction to one unpleasant morning. Elijah was afraid of going back into
his own kitchen. Mrs. Parker guided him to the sofa and sat beside him.
Marcus returned home. Laura was pacing between the island and the
pantry. The strap remained on the counter.

“You embarrassed me in front of the children,” she said.

“You were about to hit a nine-year-old with a leather strap.” “He pushed
Owen.” “After both children poured milk on him while you watched.” “They
were playing.” “Elijah was sitting on the floor asking you for help.”
Laura’s jaw tightened.

“He is always asking for something.

He wants attention. He wants everything to be about him.” Marcus looked
at the empty milk carton and the phone still playing on the counter.

“You saw them do it.” “I was busy.” “You were watching a movie.” Laura
snatched up her phone.

“You have no idea how hard it is managing three children while you’re
away.” Marcus took a slow breath.

“Then tell me what happened.

Start at the beginning.” She offered a version in which Elijah had been
difficult, Owen had accidentally spilled milk, and the strap had been
taken out only to frighten him into behaving. Her explanation changed
twice in five minutes. Marcus did not argue. He took photographs of the
kitchen, the wet clothes, and the strap. He saved the messages on his
phone and called his mother, Denise Reed, asking her to come over.

When he returned to Mrs. Parker’s house, Elijah had changed into a dry
sweatshirt. He was holding a mug with both hands.

“Can I go home now?” he asked.

Marcus sat beside him.

“Not until I know it’s safe.” Elijah stared into the cocoa.

“Maybe I shouldn’t have pushed Owen.” “We will talk about that.

You can be responsible for pushing him without accepting blame for what
they did to you.” The boy looked up.

“No.

Again. Elijah looked toward his father. I’m glad you told me.” Then
Elijah whispered something that made his father go still.