He was noticing now, and the discovery came too late to help her. Mrs. Edith Fenwick arrived in the morning room with a ledger under her arm and flour on one sleeve. Alexander apologized for drawing her away from the kitchens. She regarded him with the clear, practical gaze that had survived 20 years of running a noble household.
“If the question concerns deliveries, Your Grace, I would rather answer it now than have another month’s accounts blamed on my staff.”
He showed her three entries. Oil for the lamps, linen for the guest bedrooms, a quantity of preserved fruit beyond anything the household would ordinarily use.
“Were these delivered?”
“Some of the oil, yes, not the full amount. The linen never came to me, and no one in the kitchen ordered that much fruit.”
“Could it have been stored elsewhere?”
“If so, someone has neglected to tell the person responsible for using it.”
She paused.
“Miss Hartwell asked me similar questions several days ago.”
Alexander lowered the ledger.
“What did you tell her?”
“What I have told you.”
She made a note, then said she would ask Mr. Mercer whether the estate office had entered the wrong figures. Benedict brought his cellar and receiving books. The household possessed a clear record of every cask and crate admitted through its doors.
The discrepancies were not all enormous. That disturbed Alexander more than a single impossible sum might have done. Small amounts had been distributed through months of routine business in the hope that no one would collect them into one question.
“Mr. Mercer approves these payments?”
“He approves what the estate office pays,” Benedict answered. “Miss Hartwell has authority to check what is needed and received, but she does not draw against the estate accounts.”
Alexander turned a page. Several charges bore the name of a transport concern associated with Victor Creswell. Others concerned goods that should have moved through that concern. Nothing yet proved deliberate theft. Goods were delayed, papers misplaced, clerks fallible.
He had known honest stewards to defend errors fiercely rather than confess embarrassment. Still, the timing struck him. 14 days earlier, a locked outbuilding beyond the western fields had been reported broken into. Cloth and lamp oil intended for estate cottages was said to have been stolen. Gideon had supervised the response, presented a list of losses, and urged Alexander to approve fresh purchases before colder weather set in.
Alexander had approved them. He remembered the irritation of believing that men who depended on his wages were being robbed of winter supplies. He had offered a reward for information. No thief had been found.
“Where was Creswell’s wagon on the day of the theft?” he asked.
Benedict could not say. Edith remembered only that the replacement orders had appeared very quickly afterward. Alexander laid both sets of accounts side by side. An honest explanation remained possible. An unpleasant explanation was beginning to appear more likely.
He made a list of the documents he needed. Original orders, receipts from the carrier, the inventory from the damaged storehouse, and independent evidence of payments made. He asked that every paper be kept in its proper office, and that copies be taken in Benedict’s presence. None was to be altered, discarded, or quietly corrected.
