“Would you like me to question the servants?” Benedict asked.
“Not as suspects. Ask what they witnessed and record it plainly. I will not have this household frightened because someone else may have committed a wrong.”
The butler nodded, apparently relieved. At 9, Gideon’s office messenger brought word that the steward would return from his northern inspection the next day. Alexander sent a request for a meeting and for the relevant accounts. Then he went to the entrance hall. The small brass key was still on the table.
He picked it up, feeling the worn teeth and the warmth acquired from his fingers. It belonged to the housekeeper’s workroom, where Evelyn had balanced household books for 2 years. The key had opened a door. It had not made the room hers. Perhaps that difference was one he had never properly considered.
He did not go into her old room. Neither did he ask Benedict to search her boxes or retrieve her letters. If Evelyn was in danger, violating her privacy would only prove the worst of what she feared about a powerful man. Yet, he could not remain idle. He wrote to Samuel Pembrey, the family solicitor, requesting a discreet examination of the relevant payments and instructions for preserving the records.
Then he wrote a second, shorter note to the inn named in Evelyn’s resignation. It asked only whether Miss Hartwell was safely lodged and whether correspondence could be delivered to her there. It did not ask the keeper to report her movements. By the time he sealed the letters, darkness had settled over Blackthornne Hall. On his desk lay two pieces of paper.
One concerned the protection of his property. The other concerned the safety of a woman who no longer worked for him. He found he was far more afraid of the answer to the second. Gideon Mercer returned to Blackthornne Hall on the following morning with mud on his boots and a bundle of tenant petitions beneath his arm. At 58, he carried himself with the assurance of a man who had crossed the same thresholds for 26 years and come to believe that no door within them could be closed against him.
“Your Grace,” he said, entering the study. “Mr. Shaw tells me you have concerns about supply invoices. I trust they can be resolved without troubling the entire household.”
“I hope so. Why was Victor Creswell admitted through the service gate yesterday?”
“The fellow claimed an outstanding carrier’s charge. I authorized him to consult the receiving records.”
“Did you authorize him to confront my housekeeper?”
Gideon’s expression scarcely moved.
“Miss Hartwell has resigned. I understand. I did not know she had concerns requiring your attention.”
Alexander watched him. It was possible to speak the literal truth while carefully keeping the important truth out of sight.
“She reported shortages in goods paid for from estate funds,” Alexander said. “You told her the matter would be examined.”
“And so it shall be. A misdirected delivery is hardly a catastrophe.”
“Then there will be no difficulty providing the carrier’s receipts, the signed orders, and an explanation of the missing goods.”