Silas walked out before frustration made him say something cruel. Winter came early. Snow covered the sagebrush, and Red Mesa settled beneath a gray sky. Slowly, Eliza stopped behaving like a woman waiting to be sent away.
She argued with Jonah about flour. She forced injured ranch hands to take medicine. She threatened anyone who crossed her clean kitchen floor wearing muddy boots. The men adored her.
Silas tried not to. He failed. He noticed flour on her cheek when she baked. He noticed that she sang when she believed herself alone.
He noticed she always gave Thomas the largest piece of pie. He noticed she checked the back door twice every night. One night after midnight, he found her beside the stove holding a letter. Her hands were shaking.
“What happened?”
She tried to hide it. Silas waited. Finally she handed it to him. RETURN WHAT YOU STOLE.
LEAVE RED MESA. OR THE BOY DIES FIRST. Silas crushed the paper in his fist.
“I should leave,” Eliza said.
“No.”
“If I go, they’ll follow me.”
“No.”
“Silas.”
“No.”
She slammed her hands onto the table.
“You cannot solve everything by being enormous and saying no.”
“Worked fairly well so far.”
“This isn’t funny.”
“I know.”
Tears filled her eyes. Silas’s anger disappeared.
“I have buried everyone who ever tried to protect me,” she whispered.
“My mother. My father. My brother.”
Silas had never heard her mention a brother.
“I won’t bury Thomas. I won’t bury you.”
“I’m difficult to bury.”
A broken laugh escaped her. Silas reached toward her, then stopped. Eliza noticed. Slowly, she placed her hand in his.
Silas closed his fingers around it. There was no kiss. No declaration. Just two people beside a dying stove while snow tapped against the windows.
Then Thomas screamed upstairs. They ran. The boy was sitting upright in bed, staring at the window. A single word had been written in the frost from outside.
MERCER. At dawn, Silas found footprints beneath the window. One pair. Large boots.
The trail vanished near the stable. Nobody on watch had seen an intruder. Either the man knew Red Mesa extremely well, or someone inside had helped him. Suspicion spread through the bunkhouse.
Then a ranch hand disappeared. Caleb Moss was twenty-two, a good rider, and a terrible poker player. Jonah immediately called him a traitor. Silas refused to judge him.
Three days later, they found Caleb beneath an old bridge. He had been shot in the back. Inside his pocket was a page torn from Hollis’s ledger. One name had been circled in red.
Gideon Mercer. That night Silas opened the locked trunk beneath his bed. He had avoided it since his father’s death. Inside were cattle records, tax receipts, letters, and an old photograph.
Gideon Mercer stood beside a dark-haired young woman. Around her neck was a small silver locket. Silas looked toward the doorway. Eliza was standing there.
The same locket rested against her chest.
“Who was my father to you?”
Eliza stopped breathing.
“Eliza.”
“He saved my life.”
Silas waited.
“When I was nine, our house burned. My mother died. My father disappeared afterward. Gideon found me outside and took me to relatives in Santa Fe.”
“Why didn’t he ever tell me?”
“Because he was afraid.”
“Of Hollis?”
She shook her head.
“Of the man Hollis worked for.”
“Who?”
Eliza’s answer came quietly.
“Your father.”
Silas stared at her.
“No.”
“Gideon helped begin the land scheme.”
“You told me Hollis did it.”
“Hollis and Gideon were partners twenty-six years ago.”
Silas threw the photograph onto the table.
“My father died owing Hollis nearly everything.”
