He never did. Thomas went away to study law. He returned as an attorney with a particular hatred for dishonest mortgages. Eleanor remained nearby.
Her relationship with Eliza never became simple. Some wounds did not disappear merely because the person who caused them was sorry. But slowly, they learned to occupy the same room without the past filling every inch of it. Then, seventeen years after Silas and Eliza married, Thomas discovered something.
He was cataloging Gideon Mercer’s remaining papers when he noticed that the bottom of Gideon’s old trunk sounded hollow. He removed the boards. Beneath them was a sealed envelope. The handwriting belonged to Gideon.
Silas opened it at the kitchen table. Eliza stood beside him. Their children were outside. Jonah, older and gray now, was shouting instructions nobody appeared to be following.
Silas unfolded the letter. It was only one page. He read the first line. Then he sat down.
Eliza touched his shoulder.
“What is it?”
Silas handed her the letter. Gideon explained that transferring Red Mesa to Maribel Eleanor Harrow had not only been a way to keep Hollis from taking it. It fulfilled a promise Gideon had made beside the burning Harrow house. A promise to protect Eleanor’s daughter.
But the next paragraph contained a secret Gideon had carried to his grave. Silas Mercer was not Gideon Mercer’s biological son. Silas stared at the page. Eliza continued reading.
“Your mother died giving birth. Her name was Ruth Vane.”
She stopped. Vane. The surname Eliza had used for most of her life. Silas slowly looked at her.
“No.”
Eliza’s eyes widened. Ruth Vane had been Eleanor Harrow’s younger sister. For one terrible second, husband and wife simply stared at each other. Then Eliza suddenly started laughing.
Silas looked horrified.
“What could possibly be funny?”
“You didn’t finish the paragraph.”
He grabbed the letter. Gideon’s next sentence explained everything. Ruth Vane was not Eleanor’s biological sister. She had been orphaned as a child and raised by Eleanor’s parents.
There was no blood relation between Ruth and the Harrows. Silas leaned back and stared at the ceiling.
“That man was cruel.”
Eliza wiped tears from her cheeks.
“Gideon?”
“He could have put that information in the previous sentence.”
“He waited seventeen years to frighten you from the grave.”
Silas muttered something impolite. Eliza laughed harder. Then Silas noticed one final line. His expression changed.
“What?”
Eliza asked. He read it silently. Then handed the page to her. Gideon’s last words were simple.
If the Harrow girl ever finds you, Silas, trust her. She will appear to bring trouble into your life. In truth, she may be the person who finally brings you home. Eliza stopped laughing.
Outside the kitchen window, evening sunlight stretched across Red Mesa. Their children were chasing Thomas’s children beside the barn. Jonah was still shouting. The kitchen smelled of bread.
Much of Red Mesa no longer belonged to either Silas or Eliza. They had divided large sections among the families who worked them. The ranch Gideon had once tried to save by hiding its ownership had become something neither Hollis nor Elias Harrow would have understood. A place where ownership did not have to mean power over someone else.
Silas took Eliza’s hand.
“You know what bothers me?”
She smiled.
“What?”
“I still never hired another cook.”
“You couldn’t afford one as good as me.”
“I paid more than I expected.”
Her eyebrow rose.
“Oh?”
“My peace and quiet.”
Eliza laughed. Silas pulled her closer and kissed her forehead. For most of his life, Silas Mercer had believed strength meant carrying everything alone. Gideon had believed the same thing.