Chapter 1
The recording was made before the party, and I have no idea what Bennett already knew about Declan’s plan to wreck my marriage through me.
I hadn’t meant to make such a cruel choice when I left the house that evening. At least, that was the excuse I tried to give myself later. The party was at a friend’s place in a quiet neighborhood outside Columbus, with folding tables on the patio, burgers smoking on the grill, and warm string lights hanging across the backyard. People had paper cups in their hands and country music drifting from a speaker near the porch.
Everything looked harmless. Then Declan arrived. He had been my boyfriend before Bennett, back when I was younger and mistook attention for being understood. We had been over for years, but Declan still carried himself like the ending had been temporary—like he was simply waiting for the right moment to step back into my life.
He spotted me near the drink table and smiled. That familiar smile used to make me feel chosen. Now it made me feel watched.
“Brielle,” he said, opening his arms.
I should have kept the hug brief. I should have stepped away the second his hand stayed against my back too long.
Instead, I let the moment stretch. Over Declan’s shoulder, I saw Bennett standing beside the patio door with a cup in his hand. He wasn’t talking. He wasn’t glaring. He was simply looking at us.
Declan noticed it too. His eyes flicked past me toward Bennett, then came back with a faint, knowing grin. He had always been good at finding the weakest place in a room and pressing his thumb into it.
“You seem happier tonight,” he murmured near my ear.
Maybe he expected me to deny it. Maybe he wanted me to look toward my husband and correct him.
I didn’t.
“Maybe I am,” I answered.
Bennett heard me. I knew he did.
But he didn’t react. That silence got under my skin faster than an argument would have. If he had looked jealous, I could have told myself it meant he cared. If he had confronted Declan, I could have acted offended and turned it into Bennett’s problem.
But Bennett just stood there, quiet and still. So I decided to force a reaction out of him. Declan wandered toward one of the patio chairs and dropped into it like he belonged there. Then he patted his thigh with a laugh, making it look like some stupid party joke.
I knew exactly what he was inviting me to do. And I did it anyway. The second I sat on his lap, the conversation around us thinned out. It wasn’t completely silent, but people suddenly seemed very interested in their drinks, the grill, the lights—anything except what I had just done.
Declan’s arm slid around my waist. Across the patio, Bennett didn’t move. One of Declan’s friends laughed loudly enough for everyone to hear.
“Bennett, you better watch out. Looks like Brielle still knows where she fits.”
