A few people laughed with him. Not because it was funny. Because people laugh when they don’t know what else to do.
Declan looked pleased with himself, like the whole night had finally become the show he wanted. I could feel his chest move beneath me as he chuckled, and something in me should have recognized how ugly the moment was. Instead, I looked directly at Bennett.
“Relax,” I said.
“It’s only a party.”
The words came out sharper than I expected.
I wanted him to snap. I wanted him to tell me I was humiliating him. I wanted him to demand that I get off Declan’s lap so I could pretend I had been pushed into this.
But Bennett’s expression barely changed. He set his cup on the edge of the table with careful hands. Then he looked at me—not at Declan, not at the people watching us—and his voice was so controlled that it made my stomach tighten.
“Enjoy your win, Brielle.”
That was all. No shouting. No accusations. No public scene for me to twist into proof that he was controlling or insecure.
Bennett turned, crossed the yard, and went through the side gate. For a second, nobody said anything. Then I laughed.
It was a terrible sound—too quick, too thin—but I made myself keep smiling because everyone was staring. Declan squeezed my waist as if I had just proven something for both of us.
“There,” he said quietly.
“That’s the Bennett you married. He’d rather disappear than fight for you.”
I should have been angry at him for saying it. Instead, I watched the gate sway after Bennett left and wondered why I didn’t feel victorious at all. Five minutes passed.
Maybe less. I was still sitting there when my phone buzzed against the side of my purse. The sound was small, but it cut through every voice around me.
I pulled out my phone. The message was from Bennett. There were no words beneath his name. No argument. No question. No warning that he was coming back.
Just an audio attachment. Declan saw the screen before I could press it. His face changed so fast I almost missed it. The smug look disappeared. His fingers slipped away from my waist. Even the color drained from his cheeks.
“Don’t play that,” he said under his breath.
I stared at him.
“What is it?”
“Brielle, seriously. Not here.”
The confidence he had been wearing all night was gone. He wasn’t teasing me anymore. He wasn’t trying to provoke Bennett through me.
He was scared. And suddenly Bennett’s calm made sense in a way that frightened me more than anger ever could. He hadn’t walked out because I had beaten him. He hadn’t left because he was embarrassed, heartbroken, or too weak to fight back.
He had left because he already knew something. Something Declan had said before he even came through that gate. My thumb hovered over the audio file while Declan leaned closer, his voice low and urgent.
“You don’t understand what you’re about to hear.”