Chapter 4

I looked down at the third attachment. My thumb hovered over it, but another notification flashed across the top of my screen. The front-door camera had detected movement. I opened the alert.

The video showed Owen stepping out of my house through the side gate, wearing a baseball cap low over his face. He did not look hurried. He looked comfortable, like he had left that way before. A few seconds later, Sabrina appeared in the frame. She stood on the porch in a pale blue sweater, one hand holding her phone.

Her eyes swept across the street, then paused on the driveway. Even through the grainy camera footage, I saw the exact second she realized my truck was gone. Her expression changed. Not panic. Not guilt. Calculation.

She went back inside, and less than a minute later, my phone rang.

“Sabrina,” I said, answering carefully.

“Hey,” she said. Her voice was warm, almost playful. “You sound distracted. Everything okay at work?”

“Just a long day.”

“I figured.” She gave a small laugh. “You know what? Don’t rush home. I may run out for a few things anyway.”

I closed my eyes. She had just seen that I was not where I was supposed to be. And instead of asking why, she was creating a reason for herself to leave the house.

“You do that,” I told her.

When the call ended, I sent the camera clip to a private folder, then took screenshots of every message she had sent me that day. My hands had stopped shaking. Alden was still on the line.

“You should not confront her alone,” he said. “Not until you know what you’re dealing with.”

I watched Sabrina’s front porch through the camera feed. A few minutes later, she emerged carrying a large tote bag I had never seen before. She locked the door, walked to her car, and placed the bag in the trunk before driving away. The house stood empty.

For the first time since I had heard that voice upstairs, I had a clear chance to go inside. But I did not start the car. I tapped the audio recording instead. Static crackled for two seconds. Then Owen’s voice came through the speaker, younger but unmistakable.

“He still thinks this wedding is about love.”

There was a pause. Then Sabrina answered, calm and certain.

“It has to look like love,” she said. “That’s the only way Preston will never ask why I needed him to marry me.”

The recording cut off there. The recording ended so abruptly that for a moment I thought my phone had lost signal. I played it again. Owen’s voice came first, careless and certain.

“He still thinks this wedding is about love.”

Then Sabrina, calm enough to make my skin crawl:

“It has to look like love. That’s the only way Preston will never ask why I needed him to marry me.”

Nothing after that. No explanation. No argument. Just the soft click of a door somewhere in the old office and a burst of static before the file cut out. I pressed the phone against my ear, as if listening harder could pull the rest of the conversation out of the silence.