“I wasn’t planning to.”
“You may not get to choose,” he said.
At that exact moment, a new email arrived from an address I didn’t recognize. There was no greeting, no signature, and no explanation. Just a single attachment labeled: FOR PRESTON.
I hesitated before opening it. It was a photograph of my own kitchen table. Taken from inside my house. The picture had been captured minutes earlier. I recognized the sunlight across the hardwood floor and the bowl of lemons Sabrina kept near the window.
In the center of the table sat the large tote bag she had carried out of the house. The zipper was open. Inside were folders, envelopes, and a stack of documents held together with a gold binder clip. On top was something I recognized immediately. A pale blue envelope from our wedding venue.
My stomach dropped. Sabrina had saved every piece of our wedding planning paperwork in that envelope. The deposits, the guest list, the catering estimate, the handwritten notes from my mother about the rehearsal dinner. Why would she have it in a tote bag six years later?
I zoomed in on the photo. Beside the envelope was a file folder with a label written in black marker.
MONROE.
Sabrina’s maiden name. The same name she had used on Alden’s complaint two weeks after she became Sabrina Hale.
Chapter 6
The name I had dismissed as a technicality. The name she had kept alive as an escape route. My hand began shaking again, but this time I forced myself to keep looking. Beneath the Monroe folder was a shipping label from one of those small packages that had arrived at our house over the last year. I remembered seeing it on the porch and carrying it inside without thinking twice.
The label was addressed to S. Monroe. Not Sabrina Hale. Sabrina had not just kept her old name on one suspicious document. She had been using it long after our wedding, right under my roof.
Alden spoke carefully.
“What are you looking at?”
I told him. For the first time since I called him, he sounded genuinely alarmed.
“Preston, that may be why she married you.”
“What does that mean?”
“I found records years ago that suggested she had been trying to separate parts of her life,” he said. “One version of Sabrina was the wronged employee. Another was the devoted fiancée. But I never knew what the third version was.”
My phone lit up again. This time, it was a video call from Sabrina. I let it ring once. Twice. Then I answered.
Her face filled the screen. She was sitting somewhere dim, not at home and not in her car. Her makeup was perfect. Her hair was brushed. She looked composed enough to be heading into a meeting.
Behind her, I heard Owen’s voice. Not close enough to see him. Close enough to know he was there. Sabrina gave me a small, almost sympathetic smile.
“You found the old files.”