Chapter 3
Erin’s head turned sharply.
“You told me you couldn’t.”
“I lied.”
“You lied to me?” she said, stepping toward him. “After everything I paid you to do?”
The words landed harder than any confession of an affair could have. I looked from Erin to Graham.
“You paid him?”
Erin closed her eyes for one second. When she opened them, the fear was gone. In its place was something colder and more deliberate.
“Yes,” she said. “I hired Graham six months ago.”
The admission sat between us.
“He wasn’t supposed to come inside our home,” she continued. “He was supposed to find out who had been sending the photographs. He was supposed to identify the person following you.”
Graham gave a humorless laugh.
“That was before I realized Erin had left out the most important part.”
“What part?” I asked.
Neither of them answered immediately. Then I noticed something strange in the old fundraiser photograph. Graham stood beside me near the edge of the frame. Erin stood in the background by the service door. But there was a third person between us, mostly hidden by my shoulder. At first I had taken him for another guest in a tuxedo.
Now I saw the detail that made my breath catch. He wore the same silver watch as mine. Not one similar to it. The same narrow scratch crossed the clasp.
I looked down at the watch Graham had dropped onto the bed. My watch had been missing for four months. Yet the photograph had been taken ten years ago.
“That’s impossible,” I said.
Graham’s face lost what little color it had left. Erin stepped closer, her eyes fixed on the photograph.
“No,” she whispered. “That’s why I hired you.”
I turned the picture over again. Beneath the date in Erin’s handwriting, there was another line I had missed because her pen had bled into the paper. It read:
He wore it before Darren ever owned it.
Graham took one step toward the door.
“I need to tell you who that man is,” he said. “But if I do, you’re going to understand why Erin never wanted you to see this photo.”
“The man in the photograph is Calvin Rusk,” Graham said.
The name meant nothing to me, but Erin’s reaction did. Her fingers curled around the edge of the dresser, and for one brief second, she looked less afraid of what Graham might say than of what I would do after hearing it.
“He worked security for the foundation,” Graham continued. “Not just at that fundraiser. He handled private events for years. Your father knew him.”
“My father knew hundreds of people,” I said. “That doesn’t explain why this man is wearing my watch ten years before I owned it.”
“It was never yours first,” Graham replied.
The words hit harder than they should have. I looked down at the silver watch lying on the bedspread. I had worn it almost every day since my father gave it to me after college. He told me it had belonged to his father before him, a family piece he wanted me to keep safe. He had never mentioned Calvin Rusk.
Graham nodded toward the photo.
“Your dad took that watch from Rusk the night of the fundraiser.”
Erin shut her eyes. I turned toward her.
“You knew that?”
“I knew some of it,” she said quietly. “Not all of it.”
“That is not an answer.”
“No,” she said, meeting my stare. “It’s the truth.”
Graham stepped away from the closet and spoke faster, as though time had suddenly become more valuable than anyone’s feelings.
