“Rusk had been working around your father for months. There were questions about money connected to the foundation, records that didn’t match, donations that vanished before they reached the programs they were meant for. Your father discovered something and confronted him at that event.”

I remembered my father coming home late that night. I remembered the smell of rain on his coat and the way he locked himself in his office until morning. At the time, I had been too wrapped up in my own life to ask why his hands were shaking when he poured his coffee.

“He took the watch?” I asked.

“Rusk left it behind during the confrontation,” Graham said. “Your father kept it because he believed it proved Rusk had been there.”

“But what proof is a watch?”

Graham looked at Erin. She answered before he could.

“My guess is that it wasn’t just a watch.”

The room went silent. I stared at the narrow scratch along the clasp—the same scratch I had seen in the photograph, the same one I had always assumed came from a filing cabinet at my old job. Except it was there long before I ever touched the thing.

My father had lied to me. Or he had been trying to protect me. Before I could decide which possibility hurt worse, a sharp metallic sound came from downstairs. The back door.

Graham’s head snapped toward the bedroom window.

“That’s him.”

“You saw Calvin outside?” I asked.

“I saw someone at the gate before you came home. I thought it was a neighbor until he looked straight at me.” Graham’s face had gone pale. “He knew I was here.”

Erin moved first. She crossed the room, locked the bedroom door, then grabbed her phone from the dresser. Her hands were steady now. Controlled. The fear was still in her eyes, but she had pushed it somewhere deeper.

“Stay away from the windows,” she said. “All of you.”

I almost laughed at the absurdity of being told what to do in my own house. But then a car door slammed outside. A moment later, red-and-blue light flashed across the bedroom ceiling. Not one patrol car. Two.

Graham swore under his breath.

“What did you do?” I asked him.

“I didn’t call anyone.”

Within minutes, officers were at the front door. Erin went downstairs before either Graham or I could stop her. I followed despite her warning, with Graham behind me. The first officer was already standing in our entryway when I reached the bottom step. He was calm, professional, and clearly prepared for a story that had been given to him before he arrived.

Chapter 4

“We received a report of a possible break-in,” he said. “Caller said a man entered through the rear of the property and may be armed.”

My eyes went to Graham. He lifted both hands slowly.

“I’m not armed.”

The officer’s partner looked at the black leather bag now sitting near the foot of the stairs. I had left it upstairs. I knew I had. Erin noticed it too. Her face changed.

“That bag was in our closet,” she said. “It wasn’t down here.”

The officer glanced at her.

“Ma’am, please step back.”

“It was upstairs,” she repeated. “Someone moved it.”

But the damage was already done. Graham had a copy of our key. He had photographs of our house. He had been found in my bedroom closet holding property that belonged to me. Every fact that had terrified me an hour earlier now turned neatly against him.