Paul offered to help carry the bags. Daniel said yes. Accepting help from his brother was not the same as pretending the family had handled this well.

Upstairs, Ellie’s room was tidy in the way hotel rooms were tidy. Her blue blanket lay folded at the foot of the bed. Her rabbit sat on the dresser. Two school drawings had been pinned beside the window, and Daniel recognized his own face in one of them, wearing a uniform beneath an enormous yellow sun.

He found her suitcase in the closet. At the bottom were clean clothes he had packed, still folded as he had left them. The yellow shirt Ellie wore that evening was not among them. When he asked gently about the clothes, she said Grandma had told her to save her good ones for church and photographs. Daniel placed everything in the suitcase without comment.

Then he saw a paper tucked behind the dresser. It was a school assignment titled MY THANKSGIVING WISH. Ellie’s handwriting was uneven but clear: “I wish Daddy could come to dinner and everybody could sit together.”

He sat on the edge of the bed with the page in his hand. The wish had been written days earlier. It did not describe a sudden misunderstanding at supper. It described a child already anticipating exclusion and hoping someone would change it.

He folded the paper carefully and slipped it into his pocket. Downstairs Margaret was speaking to Paul in a brittle voice. Daniel remained where he was until he could trust himself to walk back into the room without frightening his daughter.

When he returned, Ellie was asleep on the couch, one hand buried in Buddy’s fur. Daniel woke her softly and told her they were going home. She sat up, confused.

“Did Grandma say I could?”

“You don’t need her permission. You’re coming with me.”

Ellie glanced at the dog. “Can Buddy come?”

Margaret stood in the doorway. “Absolutely not. He’s my dog.”

Daniel looked at Buddy, then at Ellie. He would not add another loss to the evening if he could help it. Paul stepped between them and offered a compromise: Buddy could stay with Paul and the children overnight, and Ellie could visit him there. Margaret objected, but the dog was already following Paul toward the front door.

Ellie accepted the arrangement reluctantly. Daniel knelt and asked if she wanted to say goodbye to Grandma. She shook her head. He did not force a hug, a thank-you, or a polite ending for the sake of appearance.

Margaret seemed stunned. “You’re taking her away on Thanksgiving?”

“I’m taking her home,” Daniel said. “Those aren’t the same thing.”

As he carried the suitcase outside, cold air rushed over the porch. Ellie clung to his hand. From the doorway, Margaret called after them that he was tearing the family apart. Daniel stopped long enough to answer.