“Don’t make a scene. Ellie wanted to eat downstairs.”

Daniel looked at his daughter. “Is that true?”

Ellie’s fingers tightened around his uniform. She did not speak.

Vanessa stepped closer. “She’s been difficult lately. She refuses meals, makes messes, and gets jealous of Ava. I’m trying to teach her boundaries.”

“Boundaries?” Daniel repeated.

Grant shifted in his chair. The stranger in Daniel’s robe avoided his eyes. Vanessa said the basement was warmer than it looked and that Ellie liked having a quiet place. Daniel glanced at the cold concrete floor and the blanket beside the furnace. There was no bed, no lamp, and no door that closed.

Ava watched from her chair. She looked uncomfortable, but Vanessa touched her shoulder and told her to finish her dinner.

Daniel carried Ellie to the kitchen and opened the refrigerator. There were containers of food, fresh fruit, desserts, and a tray of untouched ham. He warmed a proper meal and sat beside his daughter while she ate. She took small bites and kept looking at Vanessa.

“Can I have the rest?” Ellie asked when he offered another potato.

“All of it, if you’re still hungry.”

Vanessa crossed her arms. “You’re rewarding her behavior.”

Daniel did not raise his voice. “I’m feeding my child.”

The stranger finally spoke. “Maybe this is a private family matter.”

Daniel turned toward him. “Who are you?”

The man hesitated. Vanessa answered too quickly. “This is Richard. He’s a business associate.”

Richard wore Daniel’s robe, stood in Daniel’s house, and spoke as if he belonged there. Daniel felt a second truth beginning to surface.

After Ellie had eaten, Daniel took her upstairs to find warm clothes. The pink bedroom she had described was now decorated with Ava’s name. A new vanity stood beneath the window, and the shelves held dolls and framed photographs. Ellie’s old drawings had been removed. Her bed had become a daybed piled with decorative pillows.

“Where are your things?” Daniel asked.

“In the basement box.”

He opened the closet. Vanessa’s coats filled one side. Ava’s dresses filled the other. There was no space for Ellie.

Daniel found a small suitcase under the bed. Inside were clothes that had become too short, a photograph of Ellie’s late mother, and a stuffed rabbit with one missing button eye. He sat on the edge of the mattress and held the photograph.

Ellie’s mother, Claire, had died when Ellie was four. Vanessa had entered their lives the following year. Daniel had been cautious, but Vanessa seemed patient and affectionate. She told him she wanted to build a home where both girls could feel secure. He had believed her.

“Did you ask to move downstairs?” he said.

Ellie shook her head.

“Did you do something wrong?”

She looked confused. “Vanessa said Ava needed the room because she was older and had more things.”

Daniel brushed a curl away from her cheek. “You are not less important because you have fewer things.”

A sound came from the hallway. Vanessa stood in the doorway, her face tense. She said Daniel was upsetting Ellie by asking questions and that they should discuss it privately.

“Not while she thinks she has done something wrong,” he replied.

Vanessa lowered her voice. “You’ve been away. You don’t understand what this house needs.”

Daniel looked at the empty bed. “Then explain why my daughter has no bedroom.”

Vanessa said the arrangement was temporary. Ava had been having nightmares, she explained, and needed a proper room. Ellie was younger and easier to settle downstairs. Daniel asked why no one had mentioned it in their calls. Vanessa said she had not wanted to distract him while he was serving.