Their fathers had arranged the match when Eleanor was 19. It was land and old friendship and convenience. There was no grand passion in it, but there was affection and there was a promise. For 6 years, Eleanor had built her whole future around that promise.

She knew he took his coffee with three sugars. She knew he hated thunder. She knew he turned his signet ring round and round on his finger whenever he was frightened. He was turning it now.

“Eleanor,” he said, and his voice cracked. “Please, we never meant to hurt you.”

She looked at him. She looked at the ring. She felt something inside her chest go very cold and very still, like a pond freezing over in a single night.

“How long?” she asked.

Edmund opened his mouth. Lydia got there first.

“Since Christmas,” she whispered.

She was already crying. Of course she was.

“Oh, Nell, please don’t hate me. We tried so hard not to. We truly did, but you can’t argue with your own heart. It just happens.”

“Since Christmas?”

Eleanor counted backward without meaning to. Christmas. When Edmund had kissed her cheek under the mistletoe in front of the whole family and called her his dearest girl. When she had stayed up three nights straight balancing the quarter day accounts so there would be a goose on the table.

“I see,” she said.

“You must understand,” Edmund said desperately. “You’ve always managed everything, Eleanor. The house, the tenants, your father. You’d manage perfectly well without me. Lydia wouldn’t.”

There it was. It went into her like a blade slipped between the ribs so clean and quick that for a moment she didn’t even feel it. “You’d manage perfectly well without me.” Eight years of carrying a family on her back and that was her reward. She was too useful to be loved. Lydia stepped forward wiping her eyes.

“And you needn’t go anywhere, Nell. Truly, Edmund and I talked about it. You can come and live with us at Wexmore. You can help with the house and the gardens. You’ve always loved Mama’s roses. We’d never turn you out.”

Eleanor stared at her little sister. She saw it then. The whole of the rest of her life laid out in front of her like a road.

The spinster aunt, poor jilted Miss Ashcombe living on her sister’s charity in a back bedroom at Wexmore, keeping Lydia’s household books for her, standing at the christening of Edmund’s son, being pitied at every dinner for the next 40 years. “Too clever by half,” people would whisper. “Couldn’t keep him.”

“That’s very generous of you, Lydia,” Eleanor said quietly.

Lydia’s face lit up with relief.

“Then you’re not angry?”

Eleanor didn’t answer. She was looking past them both to the doorway where her father had just come in. He was not angry. That was the first thing she noticed.

A man whose eldest daughter had just been jilted by her own sister ought to be shouting. Lord Ashcombe was not shouting. He was red in the face and looking at the carpet and he would not meet her eyes.