Elizabeth stared.

She did not remember ever seeing it before.

“What’s this?”

Nobody answered.

She removed the photograph.

The paper surrounding it had been folded with unusual care.

Elizabeth opened it.

The picture showed two men standing in front of the Hart ranch.

One was Gabriel Morgan.

The other was her father.

Thomas Hart.

Elizabeth’s heart stopped.

For several seconds, she could only stare.

Her father’s familiar face looked back at her.

His broad shoulders.

His gentle eyes.

The slight crookedness of his smile.

She had spent so many lonely nights wishing she could see that smile once more.

Now it was resting in her hands.

“Papa,” she whispered.

Gabriel stood completely still.

Elizabeth studied the picture.

Her father was wearing his old brown coat.

Gabriel stood beside him, one hand resting against a fence post.

They looked comfortable together, like men who had known each other for years.

Elizabeth remembered how deeply her father had trusted Gabriel.

She remembered finding them seated on the porch late at night, speaking quietly after everyone else had gone to bed.

Sometimes, when they noticed her watching, they stopped talking.

She had assumed they were discussing cattle or ranch business.

Now she wondered what had really occupied those long conversations.

“Where did this come from?” she asked.

Cora swallowed.

“It belongs to you, dear.”

“That isn’t what I asked.”

The elderly woman looked at Gabriel.

Elizabeth followed her gaze.

He was staring at the photograph with an expression she could not understand.

Not surprise.

Not happiness.

Something closer to fear.

“Gabriel?”

He did not answer immediately.

Elizabeth looked back at the picture.

Then she noticed something strange.

The photograph seemed newer than the others her father had left behind.

Its paper had barely faded.

The edges were clean.

She turned it slightly toward the sunlight.

There was something in the background.

Behind the two men stood the eastern side of the family barn.

Elizabeth knew every board in that building.

She had helped her father replace the roof.

She had painted the doors with her own hands.

She remembered the summer she accidentally spilled an entire bucket of blue paint across the entrance.

Her father had laughed until his face turned red.

But the barn in the photograph did not look exactly as it had when her father disappeared.

The old wooden water tank was missing.

In its place stood the new iron tank Elizabeth had purchased the previous autumn.

Her breath caught.

That tank had not existed when her father was alive.

She moved the photograph closer.

Perhaps she was mistaken.

Perhaps the angle was confusing.

Perhaps someone had altered an old picture.

Then she saw something that made the blood drain from her face.

On the barn door was a white star.

A crooked white star with one point slightly shorter than the others.

Elizabeth knew that star.

She had painted it herself only three weeks earlier.

She remembered the afternoon perfectly.

The paintbrush had slipped when Hope nudged her shoulder.