Her voice softened.
“He had the most terrible singing voice.”
Caleb smiled.
“Did he?”
“Absolutely terrible.”
“Did he know?”
“Oh, yes.”
Rose laughed at the memory.
“He said a man with a voice like his ought to sing twice as loudly, just to make certain everyone suffered equally.”
Caleb laughed. Rose’s smile grew warmer.
“He used to sing while repairing fences or chopping wood. Sometimes I could hear him from the kitchen.”
“Sounds like a good man.”
“He was.”
She paused.
“He taught me to dance.”
“I remember you telling me.”
“He wasn’t particularly good at it.”
“Then perhaps there is hope for me.”
Rose laughed.
“He always counted the steps aloud.”
“That might help.”
“And whenever I stepped on his boots, he pretended it was part of the dance.”
Caleb smiled.
“I like the sound of him.”
Rose looked down.
“He would have liked you.”
The words escaped before she could think about them. Her cheeks warmed. Caleb’s expression grew gentle.
“That would have meant a great deal to me.”
For several moments, the carriage was quiet. Rose thought of her father standing in their old sitting room, laughing as he guided her through clumsy dance steps. She remembered how safe she had felt. How certain she had been that someone would always make room for her.
Then she thought of the afternoon’s humiliation. Her hands began trembling slightly. Caleb noticed.
“Rose?”
She looked up.
“Are you all right?”
She nodded too quickly.
“Yes.”
He waited. She tried to smile.
“I’m sorry. I seem to be unusually emotional tonight.”
“You’ve had a difficult afternoon.”
“It was only a carriage seat.”
Caleb shook his head.
“I don’t think it was only a carriage seat.”
Rose stared at him. He spoke quietly.
“Sometimes a small thing hurts because it reminds us of a hundred other things.”
Her eyes filled. She looked away before he could see. But he had already noticed.
“Rose, you don’t need to pretend with me.”
The tenderness in his voice made it harder to hold back her tears. She swallowed.
“I wasn’t always treated this way.”
Caleb remained silent.
“When my father was alive, I had a place at the table. I had a place in the sitting room. I had my own little duties, of course, but I was never made to feel as though I should apologize for being there.”
She looked down at her hands.
“After he died, things changed.”
“In what way?”
Rose took a slow breath.
“Margaret began managing everything. She said we needed to be careful with money. And we did. I understood that.”
Caleb nodded.
“Then Evelyn grew older, and her future became very important.”
“Naturally.”
“Naturally,”
Rose repeated. She gave a sad little smile.