The tenderness in his voice made it harder to hold back her tears. She swallowed.

“I wasn’t always treated this way.”

Caleb remained silent.

“When my father was alive, I had a place at the table. I had a place in the sitting room. I had my own little duties, of course, but I was never made to feel as though I should apologize for being there.”

She looked down at her hands.

“After he died, things changed.”

“In what way?”

Rose took a slow breath.

“Margaret began managing everything. She said we needed to be careful with money. And we did. I understood that.”

Caleb nodded.

“Then Evelyn grew older, and her future became very important.”

“Naturally.”

“Naturally,”

Rose repeated. She gave a sad little smile.

“She needed new dresses. Lessons. Invitations. There were always people she ought to meet.”

“And you?”

Rose looked at the blanket.

“I was already useful at home.”

Caleb’s expression tightened slightly.

“Useful.”

“That’s what Margaret always said.”

She tried to make the words sound light.

“Rose is sensible. Rose understands. Rose doesn’t mind.”

A tear slipped down her cheek. She wiped it away.

“But sometimes I did mind.”

Caleb said nothing.

“Sometimes I wanted a new dress. Sometimes I wanted to spend an afternoon reading instead of mending. Sometimes I wanted to go somewhere simply because it would make me happy.”

Her voice trembled.

“And then I would feel selfish for wanting those things.”

Caleb leaned forward slightly.

“Why?”

“Because there was always something else that needed doing.”

“Rose.”

She lifted her eyes. He looked at her with quiet seriousness.

“Wanting a little happiness doesn’t make you selfish.”

Her lips trembled. She wanted to believe him. Part of her already did. But old habits were difficult to loosen.

“I don’t think Margaret means to be cruel,” she whispered.

“Perhaps not.”

“She has responsibilities too.”

“I’m sure she does.”

“And Evelyn is young.”

“Yes.”

Rose looked at him helplessly.

“Then why does it still hurt?”

Caleb’s face softened.

“Because you were hurt.”

The answer was simple. There was no anger in it. No judgment. Only understanding.

Rose looked down as another tear slipped onto the blanket. Caleb quietly offered her a clean handkerchief. She accepted it.

“Thank you.”

“You’re welcome.”

She pressed the cloth gently against her eyes. For a little while, he allowed her to sit in silence. He did not tell her to stop crying.

He did not insist that everything would be all right. He simply remained beside her while the carriage rolled through the rain. And somehow, that kindness was more comforting than any grand promise could have been.

After a while, Rose folded the handkerchief carefully.

“I’ll wash this before returning it.”

Caleb smiled.

“There’s no hurry.”

“I wouldn’t want to ruin it.”

“It’s a handkerchief, Rose.”

She laughed softly.

“Just like the carriage seat?”

“Exactly.”

He leaned back.

“I’m beginning to suspect you spend far too much time worrying about ordinary objects.”

“Perhaps.”

“And not nearly enough time thinking about yourself.”

Rose looked at him.

“Perhaps that too.”

Caleb’s smile softened.

“Well, there’s still time to change that.”

Outside, the rain began to lessen. The clouds broke in places, revealing narrow strips of pale evening light. Rose watched the changing sky. Then she said,

“May I ask you something?”