Crowe lunged for the tray. He was quicker than he looked and had caught its edge when Eliza moved. She hooked her foot around a leg of the stool and kicked it hard into his knees. He cried out and staggered sideways into Mrs. Pruitt, who had just appeared in the doorway with a ladle. She brought it down on his wrist with the full strength of thirty years of stirring stew. The tray clattered to the floor.
Before Crowe could recover, Mr. Vale had him by the collar and pinned against the wall, an old soldier’s forearm locked across his chest. At last, the poisoner had a face.
The magistrate arrived the next morning, after snowplows had opened a single narrow track through the drifts from town. Magistrate Thomas Harlow was a thin man with ink-stained fingers and a reputation for listening patiently to everyone. Dr. Crowe denied everything calmly and at length, insisting that the girl herself had tampered with the ginger. Lady Evelyn denied everything with a trembling voice and a handkerchief to her eyes. Then Agnes told her story again, more slowly this time and without crying, and the magistrate wrote down every word.
That afternoon, Mr. Vale and the magistrate’s constable searched Lady Evelyn’s guest chamber. In the false bottom of her writing case they found a folded letter addressed to Crowe, in her own neat, looping hand. It referred to the second measure, and to the Duke becoming more reasonable once he was sufficiently frightened for his life. Crowe’s room supplied the rest: a jar of bitter seeds, a vial of concentrated laurel extract, handwritten notes on quantities and timing, and a receipt for three jars of specially strained honey delivered to the northern garden. When the magistrate laid the letter before him, Crowe finally stopped talking.
The truth came out in pieces. At first, Lady Evelyn had wanted Adrian weak, not dead. A sick, frightened duke would sign whatever was put before him, and the canal would at last be cut through the northern valley. She had approached Crowe with flattery, then pressure, then money, and he had prepared whatever she asked. But weakness had ceased to be enough. The dose in the silver cup had been meant to kill.
Yet Eliza noticed something the magistrate seemed willing to overlook. The ginger had been firmly established by Agnes’s account, the letter, and the sample. The first poisoning had not. No one had seen who poured the honey into the Duke’s cup, and the honey might have passed through a dozen hands in the kitchen. Crowe swore he had supplied only medicinal plants, not the dose. Lady Evelyn swore she had never set foot in the northern garden. The narrow footprints proved that someone had been there, but not who.
Proving what had happened on the night of the banquet would require a long, careful trial. Eliza knew that careful trials sometimes ended with powerful people walking away. As the constable led them off in irons, the household gathered in the passage to watch. Some of the servants cheered. Mrs. Pruitt wept into her apron, then ordered everyone back to work.