The tall gentleman had come out from under the arch into the rain. He did not look at the horse. He looked at the girl holding it. He looked at her boots, which were a man’s boots, then at her hands, red to the wrist, cracked across the knuckles the way a farrier’s are. They were the hands of somebody who worked out of doors in September without gloves.
“Open his mouth, please,” he said.
His voice was quiet, and he did not say it twice. Catherine put her thumb in at the bar of the colt’s mouth and turned the lip up. She knew what was there. She had known since April when the brown came home from a dealer at Ashbourne, and her aunt paid 90 guineas for him and told everybody she had bred him. The marks in the lower teeth were black and neat and much too tidy for a 5-year-old. Somebody had taken a small iron and burnt them in, and then rubbed them and made a neat piece of work of it.
But you cannot burn the shape of a tooth. You cannot make the corner tooth come up round when the years have made it flat. Nor can you alter the way the front teeth meet, which in an old horse goes slanting, like two hands set together at the fingertips. The stud groom Miller looked. He had been 40 years in the trade and he saw it and she watched him decide not to say it in front of a lady.
“Very nice,” said Miller.
“He is not five, sir,” said Catherine.
It came out level. She had not intended to say anything at all. She had gone 10 years saying nothing, which is a skill like any other, and can be kept up indefinitely. She heard her own voice go across the wet yard.
She knew she had spent something she could not get back. Her aunt’s face did not change. That was the thing about her. Her face never changed.
“Catherine…”
“He is eight,” Catherine said, “perhaps nine. The mark has been burnt in and it is very well done. But the corner tooth is round and the bite is gone. He’s a good honest horse and he will hunt for another five seasons and he’s not worth 120 guineas because he’s not rising five.”
Nobody said anything. The rain came down the arch in a rope and hit the cobbles and split.
“My niece is fond of horses,” said Mrs. Critow pleasantly.
“So I see,” said the tall man.
“She has been the greatest help to me. But she has no head for business and she was not brought up to it and she does not always understand what she is looking at.”
“On the contrary,” he said, “I think she understands exactly what she is looking at.”
He turned and put his hand on the colt’s neck. And then he looked at Catherine over the animal’s crest, and she saw his eyes properly for the first time, pale gray green, like water over stone. His hair was dark and going gray early at the temples, which made him look older than he was until you looked again.