The weather broke over Cresbrook Dale a little after 4:00 on the first Thursday of September in the year 1816. It came down off the moor in a long gray wall, and the sheep saw it first. They left the high pasture in single file without hurry, the way sensible people leave a room where a quarrel is about to start. There had been no summer that year. There had been a wet spring and a wet June.

The oats were still green in August, and the farmers of the Dale had stopped talking about the harvest, the way a house goes quiet around a sick child. Cecilia Crancliffe watched the mist come from the top of a dry stone wall with a leather writing case on her knees. She judged that she had a quarter of an hour. She was 24 years old, thin in the wrists, with dark hair under a bonnet that had been her cousin’s. And on the second finger of her right hand was a small blue stain that no soap had ever shifted.

On the far side of the wall stood two stone gate posts with no gate between them. Beyond the posts, a long drive climbed between black yews toward the house called Stonegill. Every child in the Dale had been dared to touch those posts. Most of them had done it and run.

“You needn’t, of course,” said her cousin Charlotte, who stood in the road, holding her skirts out of the mud. “Nobody would think any the less of you.”

Charlotte Furness was 22 and the prettiest girl between Bakewell and Tideswell, and had been told so early enough for it to do lasting harm. Behind her, her sister Kitty laughed because Charlotte had paused in the place where a laugh was wanted. It had begun at the breakfast table, as most of Charlotte’s cruelties did. Cecilia had mentioned that she had a letter for the carrier addressed to the Duke of Coatsbury. Charlotte had asked whether that made a hundred.

For 7 years, she said, Cecilia had been begging that man for mercy on behalf of every old woman in the Dale in her beautiful penmanship. And had he ever once answered kindly? If she was so sure of her fine words, why not carry them up there herself? Why not knock at his door? And Cecilia, who almost never answered, had put down her spoon and said:

“What will you give me if I do?”

The table had gone quiet. Charlotte had looked at the shelf above the dresser. She had smiled and said:

“Your mother’s flower book.”

The book had been in the house for 15 years. It had come to the farm in the same cart as Cecilia. The winter her mother died, and her aunt had given it to Charlotte because a child of nine would only spoil it. A child of seven had spoiled it a little instead. Cecilia had not been allowed to open it since, and had long ago stopped asking, so here they were.