He was less certain of himself where Martha Lane was concerned. At the Lane farm, the winter dance drew closer with every passing day. The blue silk gown was finished first. Lucy tried it on before the mirror while their mother examined the seams, adjusted the fabric at her shoulders, and stepped back to admire the result.

It was a lovely dress. The rich color made Lucy’s eyes appear brighter, and the silk moved gracefully when she turned. Her hair had been carefully arranged, and even without the chandeliers and music of the dance hall, she looked ready for a celebration. Mrs.

Lane was delighted.

“There,” she said.

“No one will overlook you.”

Lucy smiled at her reflection.

“Do you truly think so?”

“I know so.”

Martha stood nearby, holding a loose thread she had removed from the hem.

“You look beautiful, Lucy.”

Her younger sister turned toward her.

“Thank you.”

For a moment, Lucy’s eyes rested on Martha’s plain dress.

“Come here,” she said.

“What for?”

“I want to see us together.”

Martha laughed.

“Why?”

“Because we’re sisters.”

Martha stepped beside her. Their reflections made an unusual pair. Lucy wore brilliant blue silk, with every fold arranged to flatter her figure. Martha stood in faded work clothes, her hands slightly rough from the cold and her hair pinned back without decoration.

Yet their faces shared enough family resemblance to make their relationship unmistakable. Lucy tilted her head.

“We look different.”

“We always have.”

“Mother says I favor her.”

“You do.”

“And you?”

Martha studied her reflection.

“I’m not sure.”

Lucy looked at her more closely.

“You know, if you wore something finer, you might surprise everyone.”

Martha smiled.

“Would that be a good thing?”

“Of course.”

“Then perhaps I’ll surprise them by being myself.”

Lucy rolled her eyes, but she was smiling.

“You make everything so difficult.”

“That’s what Mother says.”

They laughed together. For a brief moment, neither sister seemed worried about the dance or what might happen there. Then Mrs. Lane returned to the room with another question about Lucy’s appearance, and the familiar arrangements resumed.

Martha withdrew to finish repairing her own gown. The brown dress lay across her lap that evening while the rest of the household grew quiet. Its sleeves had begun to wear thin near the wrists. She examined the fabric carefully before choosing thread that would blend as closely as possible with the faded color.

The repair would be visible to anyone who looked closely. But the sleeves would be strong. Martha preferred that. She sewed by the warm light of a lamp, listening to the familiar sounds of the house settling around her.

At one point, she lifted the gown and held it against herself. The dress had once been prettier. She remembered wearing it when the fabric still held its original rich brown shade and the seams were new. Over time, work and washing had softened it, and careful mending had kept it useful long after a more fashionable woman might have put it aside.

She wondered briefly how she would look beneath the chandeliers. Then she folded the gown and laid it away. The thought embarrassed her. It was only a dance.

She had attended gatherings before and survived the disappointment of being passed over by men who preferred a brighter smile or a more expensive dress. Yet she could not quite dismiss the small wish that had risen unexpectedly in her heart. She wanted someone to ask her to dance because he genuinely wished to spend time with her. Not because there were no other women available.

Not because her mother had arranged the introduction. Not because he felt sorry for her. She wanted to be chosen freely. The wish felt foolishly large for such a simple thing.

She reached for her sewing again. The last stitch was nearly finished when she remembered Ethan, the traveler with the lame horse. He had spoken to her as though what she thought mattered. He had thanked her without making her feel beneath him.

And he had looked at her with an interest that seemed untouched by the worn condition of her clothing. Martha set the needle down. She wondered where he had gone. Perhaps he had returned to whatever ranch employed him.

Perhaps he had found better work somewhere beyond the valley. Perhaps he had forgotten the farm entirely. There was no reason he should remember her. She had given him supper, helped him care for his horse, and sent him on his way.

Nothing more. Still, when she imagined the winter dance, the kind of man she wished might ask for her hand looked strangely like the muddy stranger in the barn. She shook her head at herself.

“You’re being foolish,” she whispered.