“He paid every debt Lord Miles left,” Bessie said, weeping now, past caring. “Every one in secret, so no tradesmen went unpaid. He sold his own hunters. He let his house in the country stand half shut, and he swore to Cassandra at the last. I was there, miss. I held her hand and his both. He swore the child would never know her father died, a ruined gamester who ran into the snow. She made him swear it, her last strength going into the swearing. She wanted Winnie to have a father to be proud of, even a dead one. And he swore.”

The old woman pressed her worn hands to her face.

“And now they call him cruel and cold. And I cannot bear it, miss. And I am too old, too poor, to do anything to stop them.”

“Bessie,” Selena said very carefully, an idea just beginning to move in the dark of her mind. “You said Cassandra made him swear at the last. Did she? Was there anything written? A letter? Anything in her own hand.”

The old woman went still. Her wet eyes came up, and there was something in them. Some old buried thing surfacing, and then a scrape of feet in the passage, and Mrs. Kemp’s voice calling, and Bessie flinched like a struck thing, and clapped her mouth shut.

“I have said too much again,” she whispered. “Always too much. No, no, there is nothing. Leave it, miss. Leave the dead alone.”

She gathered herself up and hobbled away and would not speak of it again. Selena watched her go. The old woman was frightened, not of Selena, but of something. Some knowledge she carried like a stone in her apron, and dared not set down.

And then two things happened close together, and the shape of the whole thing began to come clear. The first was Rudd. A footman turned off Thorndale 6 months before for petty thieving, let go without a public matter, because the Duke would not make one even of that. Selena found him at dusk at the servant’s door, where he had no business.

“Evening, miss,” he said, grinning in a voice greased all over. “Or should I say the young lady of the house.”

Within a day she had it from Mrs. Kemp. Rudd was in Mrs. Vosper’s pay now, going about the taverns and back kitchens of the square, selling the slander wholesale, the Duke a hard master, the child neglected, and there were people glad to buy. The second thing was that Regina Vosper’s next move was aimed straight at Bessie. A letter came from Scarrow, very smooth, very reasonable. Mrs. Vosper was concerned, it said, that the child was in the sole care of an aged and infirm nurse whose faculties were failing, no fit guardian of a young girl’s safety through the night. It was suggested most kindly that His Grace would do well to pension the old woman off and engage a younger, more capable person.