I hated how plainly she said it. I wanted a witness who would tell me I’d handled everything perfectly. Instead, she pointed out that the four men who believed Valerie was single had their own feelings and lives. Nolan, who had agreed to help me, now regretted doing so. None had signed up to be a character in my private revenge story.

“What do I do?” I asked.

“Start with a lawyer. Tell the truth. Don’t publish her messages. Don’t call Owen to take your side. And whatever happens to the marriage, stop setting traps.”

Monday morning I met attorney Helen Carter in a brick office across from the county courthouse. She studied the proposed separation agreement, asked about the company’s ownership, and warned me not to assume Valerie’s infidelity would automatically determine who got what. We lived in a state where property questions required records, not dramatic speeches.

When I told her about the five men, she put down her pen.

“Did you record anybody without permission?”

“No.”

“Did you hire anyone to create false evidence?”

“No.”

“Did you arrange the meetings?”

I explained. She listened and said, “Then keep every relevant communication. We are not going to turn this into a social-media spectacle, and we are not going to surprise the other side with material we can’t explain honestly.”

She wanted the financial documents handled separately. An independent accountant could review the business and the household accounts. If Valerie had copied confidential files, we’d address that with counsel. If she had merely bragged to Nolan, we’d establish that instead of inventing a crime.

Before I left, Helen asked whether I wanted to reconcile.

I stared at the carpet. It took a long time to answer.

“I want the version of her I married,” I said.

“That isn’t one of the choices on this form,” she replied.

—

Two days later, Nolan came to my office. He looked exhausted. There was no congratulatory handshake.

“I shouldn’t have agreed,” he said before sitting down.

“You made the call.”

“I know. That’s the part I regret.”

He told me he hadn’t touched Valerie’s phone, copied her private photographs, or recorded their time together. He had kept his own messages because she had discussed a possible investment in my company. He showed me the exchange in which Valerie asked whether an investor could buy a business without the owner’s agreement. Nolan had answered that buying equity required the actual owners’ consent, whatever a spouse might promise.

“She asked if a marital settlement could force a sale,” he said. “I told her that was a question for a lawyer, not a stranger she’d just met.”

I looked at him. “Did you tell her I sent you?”