“Preston? Is something wrong?”
For a second, I can’t make the words come out. I am still hearing Sabrina’s voice through that bedroom door. Finally, I say:
“I need to ask you about Sabrina.”
The silence on the line is immediate and heavy. Then Alden says quietly:
“So you finally saw something.”
My grip tightens around the phone.
“What does that mean?”
He exhales, like he has been waiting a long time to have this conversation.
“Whatever story she gave you about me, it wasn’t the whole truth. There are things you need to see.”
Chapter 2
My heart starts hammering again.
“Tell me now.”
“Not over the phone,” he says. “Check your email. I’m sending you what I kept.”
“What exactly did you keep?”
But the line has already gone dead. Less than a minute later, an email arrives. The subject line is blank. There are three attachments beneath it: a photograph, a document, and an audio recording dated eight months before Sabrina and I got married.
I stare at the screen, trying to make sense of why a man I had avoided for years would have anything connected to our wedding. Alden had sounded neither angry nor triumphant. He sounded tired.
Before I can open a single file, Sabrina calls. Her name fills my screen beside the photo I took of us on our honeymoon. For one terrible second, I almost ignore it. Then I answer because I need to know whether she can hear the change in my breathing.
“Hey, beautiful,” I say, forcing the words out evenly.
“Baby, where are you?” Her voice is light, but there is something strained beneath it.
“Wrapping up at work. Why?”
There is a pause just long enough to make my jaw clench.
“Oh, no reason,” she says. “I just wanted to hear your voice.”
Then I hear it. A man speaks in the background. Muffled, low, but unmistakably close enough that Sabrina reacts to it. She rushes to explain.
“The TV is on. I’ll call you later.”
I look through the windshield at the quiet street in front of me. A dog barks behind a fence. Somewhere nearby, a lawn mower starts up.
“Sure, sweetheart,” I tell her. “Talk later.”
She hangs up. For a moment, I sit perfectly still. The email remains open on my phone, three small attachments waiting beneath Alden’s name. I tap the photograph first.
At first, I only see Sabrina standing beside a man outside what looks like a restaurant. She is dressed up, smiling in a way I recognize too well. The man has one hand resting near her elbow, close enough to make my stomach drop. But he is not the man whose voice I heard upstairs.
I zoom in. Then I recognize him. He was beside me on my wedding day. He stood near me while I waited for Sabrina to walk down the aisle. He shook my hand, laughed with my family, and raised a glass to our future at the reception.
My pulse thunders in my ears as I look closer at the bottom of the image. There is a date printed there. And the date is from before Sabrina ever became my wife. I stare at it until the numbers stop looking real, suddenly understanding why Alden had held on to this photograph for so long.
Then my thumb hovers over the document and the recording beneath it. Because the betrayal happening upstairs is no longer the worst thing I have found.
The man in the photograph was Owen Price. For years, Owen had been one of the people I trusted most. He had stood beside me at the altar in a charcoal suit, adjusted my tie before the ceremony, and told me I was the luckiest man he knew. At the reception, he had lifted a glass and made everyone laugh with a story about how long it took me to work up the nerve to ask Sabrina out.