“Your Grace, may I ask why?”

The silence behind her stretched so long that she thought he would not answer. Then his voice came, low and flat and final.

“No, Miss Hartwell. You may not.”

Lady Philippa Marlowe was the smallest, palest, most watchful child Anna had ever seen. She sat in the window seat of the nursery with her knees drawn up beneath her nightgown and her dark hair in a tangle. And she watched Anna come in the way a wild bird watches a stranger in a garden. She had her father’s gray eyes. She did not blink.

“Good morning, Lady Philippa,” said Anna. “My name is Miss Hartwell. I am going to be your governess.”

Nothing. Anna did not press her. She had learned long ago from her father that the quickest way to frighten a shy creature was to chase it. So, she sat down at the little schoolroom table, took a pencil and a sheet of paper from her reticule and began to draw. She drew a long row of narrow rectangles side by side.

Then, carefully, she shaded in smaller, darker ones between them in groups of two and three, a keyboard, a paper pianoforte. Out of the corner of her eye she saw Philippa’s head turn. Anna laid the paper flat on the table and placed her fingers upon it. She did not make a sound. She simply moved her fingers over the drawn keys, slowly and gracefully, as though she were playing something lovely that only she could hear.

She swayed a little. She closed her eyes. She smiled. When she opened them again, Philippa was standing at her elbow. The child said nothing, but she stared at the paper keyboard, then at Anna’s hands, then, very slowly, she reached out one small finger and pressed a paper key.

“That one is called C,” Anna whispered. “It is where everything begins.”

Philippa pressed it again, and that was how it started, not with words, with silence and paper and a secret. Over the following weeks, Anna taught Lady Philippa her letters, just as the Duke had asked. She taught her to sew a straight seam and to curtsy and to follow short stories about rabbits and ponies with her finger. But in the quiet hour after luncheon, when the house was still and Mrs. Bell was busy downstairs, Anna and Philippa would sit side-by-side at the schoolroom table with the paper pianoforte between them, and Anna would teach her music without a single sound.

She taught her the names of the notes. She taught her scales by tapping softly on the table. She taught her to feel rhythm in her fingertips, steady as a heartbeat. And sometimes, when Philippa grew tired and laid her head on her folded arms, Anna would hum, very, very softly, so softly that it was barely more than breathing.

She always hummed the same tune. It was the tune her father had sung to her every night of her childhood, a lullaby, gentle and rocking, with a strange little lift at the third note that never failed to make Anna smile. Her father had taught it to her when she was 4 years old. He had never let her play it for his pupils or for anyone else.

“That one is not ours to share, my lark,” he would say. “It belongs to someone. One day, perhaps, it will go home.”

Anna had never understood what he meant. On the night he died, he had pressed a folded sheet of old music into her hands, yellowed and fragile, written in a delicate slanting hand that was not his own. Across the top, in faded ink, were the words “For my little lark.” And at the bottom, a single letter, “I.”

“Keep it safe,” he had whispered. “Promise me. I tried once to give it back, and they would not let me through the gate. Perhaps you will have better fortune.”

“Give it back to whom, Papa?”


NEXT PART: 

PART 2: “Let the Governess Play,” They Laughed — The Duke Stood Up at the Third Note