Here’s what I found.
The account overview showed only the balance. That was why I’d never noticed anything strange. But if you clicked a little tab marked “Transaction History,” it displayed everything that had moved through Brooke’s student account since she enrolled.
Every semester, I’d paid the tuition in full and on time. Beneath each of my payments, though, was another entry: Federal Graduate Loan Disbursement. And just below that was a line that said “Student Refund.”
I read it four times before it sank in.
Brooke had told me she didn’t qualify for financial aid. That was the whole reason I’d offered to pay. But every semester, she’d taken out federal graduate student loans anyway. Because I’d already paid the tuition in full, the school had no tuition balance to apply those loan proceeds against. So it did what schools do: it sent the surplus to the student as a refund for living expenses.
I added the figures on the back of an envelope. Four semesters. Roughly ninety-five hundred dollars each time. Thirty-eight thousand dollars deposited into a bank account I’d never seen, while she sat across from me month after month saying she was broke and asking me to pay for her eyelash appointments.
I’d paid her tuition, and the federal loans had put another thirty-eight thousand dollars in her hands. She’d kept every cent of it secret.
And this was the part that really made me sick. The refunds hadn’t gone into the bank account we used for groceries. The portal showed the last four digits of the receiving account, and they didn’t match any account of hers I knew about.
So where had the thirty-eight thousand dollars gone?
I sat there at three in the morning staring at that question. I couldn’t answer it. Not yet. But I can tell you that the answer ended up being a lot worse for her than it was for me.
At eight the next morning, I called the university’s billing office. A very patient woman named Gloria walked me through everything. As an authorized payer, I could withdraw at any time, and any future installments I’d set up would be canceled. The spring invoice Brooke had slid across the table hadn’t been paid yet, so it would remain on Brooke’s account in Brooke’s name.
Gloria asked whether I wanted to proceed.
“Yes,” I said.
She asked if I was sure, because the student would be notified.
“I’m very sure.”
Within an hour, she’d emailed me written confirmation.
Then I went down the list, one item at a time, the way I would finish a job. Brooke was an authorized user on my personal credit card, so I removed her. She was on my phone plan, so I started separating her line and gave her the thirty days the carrier allowed to transfer her number. She was covered under my company’s auto and health insurance, so I called my insurance agent and began the process of ending those arrangements.
I didn’t freeze anything out of spite, and I didn’t touch a single account in her name. I simply stopped paying for a woman who’d explicitly told me she was living somewhere else.
Next, I called a locksmith. New locks, a new garage-door code, a new Wi-Fi password. Three hundred ten dollars in total, worth every penny.
And instead of throwing her stuff onto the lawn, which I’ll admit crossed my mind, I spent Monday evening packing everything she owned into labeled boxes and stacking them neatly in the garage. Clothes, shoes, makeup, books, jackets I’d bought her. I even packed the dog bed she’d purchased before we had a dog. I photographed every sealed box with the date on my phone.