She recognized the duke but did not curtsy. He asked what had happened to the shops. She told him plainly. The rents had risen beyond what small tradesmen could pay. Bell’s had gone first, then the cobbler, then the candle maker. Her own shop had lasted one more spring.
Edward listened. He had expected resentment, perhaps exaggeration. Instead he heard ordinary losses, each made final by a signature on a lease. When he returned to Ashcombe Hall, he told Nora he owed Mill Street more than an apology. Nora did not thank him. An apology would not reopen a shop or restore five years of work.
Then Edward told her what he had seen outside the vicarage. Mary had been standing in the lane, laughing with James, the head footman. They had been holding hands.
Mary was not ill. She and James had been planning to marry for a year.
Nora admitted the truth. The couple had arranged a quiet wedding at dawn on Saturday, the day of the county dinner. Lady Harriet’s rule meant that both would lose their places if they married. Mary had asked Nora to take her place in the kitchen for a few days, giving her time to prepare without attracting suspicion.
Nora had come to protect her sister’s position, not to deceive the duke for amusement. Edward understood the fear behind the lie, but he knew his mother would use it as an excuse to make an example of them. He asked Nora for time to think.
Lady Harriet heard the conversation from the corridor. She did not object because she disliked Mary or James personally. She objected because a servant’s private choice might weaken the authority she had built her life around. She told Edward that the couple would be allowed to serve the dinner, but once the main course was on the table she would dismiss them in front of every guest, without references.
Edward said he would not permit it. His mother reminded him that Ashcombe Hall was her household as much as his. If he defended a woman who had once thrown a pie at him, the county would say a village baker had made a fool of the Duke of Ashcombe.
Edward did not answer. He had begun to understand that the marriage rule was not harmless tradition. It forced servants to choose between earning a living and building a family.
At dawn on Saturday, Mary and James stood in the village vicarage. Mary was pale with nerves, but her hand remained in James’s. They expected the ceremony to be brief and secret. Then the church door opened, and Edward Ashcombe entered.
Mary’s face drained of colour. James stepped forward, ready to take responsibility. Edward told him to stay where he was. He had not come to punish anyone. He had heard that the law required two witnesses, and he had come to stand as one. He signed the register in his own name.