I gently removed my hands. I asked her one question about the watch. She became completely still. Then she started to cry for real, the kind of awful crying you can’t fake. And to be honest, part of me felt it. Nine years cannot be erased just because we want them to.

But I also remembered her looking straight into my eyes, a smoothie in her hand, telling me she’d never been more serious.

“You were very clear,” I told her. “I simply listened.”

She asked where she was supposed to go. I told her the guest room was ready for the night. I had already packed her bag for tomorrow, and her mother had been waiting for her call since that afternoon. Because I had called her mother first, not to report her, but just to make sure Celeste had somewhere to go.

I’m not cruel. I’m just finished.

But here’s the thing. What happened to her that night was not karma. Karma began Monday morning at 9 a.m.
Natalie did exactly what she said she would. She sent the expense reports to Grant’s company, along with the resort booking confirmation and the spa receipt. By lunchtime, Grant had been escorted out of the building by security. It turned out this was not his first fake business trip. The audit went back two years, and each time it revealed the same pattern. Celeste’s name kept appearing in the records.

Celeste was not sent home that day. That had to wait until Thursday. The company had a strict policy on managers dating their subordinates, and an even stricter one on employees knowingly accepting company-paid trips. The promotion she had boasted about at her sister’s birthday, the one Grant had personally recommended her for, disappeared along with her access badge.

Then Briana learned from a mutual friend that Celeste had been using her name as an alibi for months. Not just for this trip. Concerts. Spa weekends. A visit to vineyards in Napa. Briana had unknowingly served as a cover for all of it.

She called me herself to apologize for laughing during that phone call.

“I thought it was just a couple’s argument,” she said. “I didn’t know I was part of the lie.”

Then she blocked Celeste everywhere.

Natalie filed for divorce the same week I did. She told me that Grant had tried to convince her the trip meant nothing. She said she asked him to repeat that while she held up the warranty card.

As for the money, Diane did what Diane always does. Every withdrawal Celeste made from the household account was documented as an expense related to an affair, and the judge didn’t like that. The court deducted the resort, the clothes, and the watch from her share. Once everything was divided, I left with more than I had put in, and Celeste left owing me the difference.

She ended up selling the white linen set online to help cover the cost. I know because Briana sent me the listing.