Malcolm Ramsey shoves a stranger away from the couch in his own living room, his unopened bakery box crushed against his side. His wife, Paige Walsh, stands nearby in a maid costume and tells him with a smile that he is no longer welcome in the house they built together.

Chapter 2

I grabbed my suitcase from the trunk, tucked the cake against my ribs, and walked up the path with a smile already forming. Then I heard music. It was coming from inside the house, louder than Paige ever played it when she was alone. Under the music was laughter—easy, loose laughter from more than one person.

I stopped with my key just inches from the lock. For a second, I told myself she must have a friend over. Maybe one of the neighbors had stopped by. Maybe there was a harmless explanation for everything I was hearing.

But there was something wrong with the sound of it. It wasn’t the laughter of people waiting for someone to come home. It was the laughter of people who believed they had the place entirely to themselves.

I unlocked the door anyway. The entryway was dark except for the light spilling in from the living room. I set my suitcase down quietly, still holding the cake box, and listened.

A man laughed again. My stomach tightened so sharply I almost dropped the dessert. I moved farther into the house, past the framed photos Paige and I had hung over the years. There was one from our anniversary trip, one from a backyard cookout, one from the day we moved in.

Every picture felt like it belonged to another couple. When I reached the living room doorway, I froze. Paige was standing beside the coffee table wearing a black-and-white maid outfit I had never seen before. It looked like a costume, with a short apron and lace trim, and it made no sense in the room where we usually ate takeout and watched TV.

She had one hand resting on the back of the couch. A man sat there like he belonged. He was relaxed, shoes off, leaning into the cushions I had picked out with Paige during our first year in the house. I had never seen him before, but he looked completely comfortable surrounded by my things.

For several seconds, neither of them noticed me. I stood in the doorway with my travel clothes still on, my suitcase abandoned behind me, and a lemon cake in my hands like some cruel joke. My mind kept searching for a harmless answer, refusing to settle on the obvious one.

Then Paige turned. Her eyes met mine. The color left her face for half a second. I saw the surprise. I saw the quick calculation behind it. And then, unbelievably, her mouth curved into a smile.

Not shame. Not fear. A smile.

The stranger looked over his shoulder, following Paige’s stare. When he saw me, he gave a short, amused laugh, as if I had interrupted a private joke instead of walked into my own home. I waited for Paige to explain.