She had the dark eyes Selena had seen in the child, for she was Winnie’s aunt, her dead mother’s elder sister, though the resemblance sat strangely on a harder face. She was all warmth in the drawing room. She wept becomingly over her poor lost sister. She held Winnie on her knee and called her “my precious lamb.”

Winnie sat rigid, endured it, and watched the door. She praised the house and pitied it in the same breath which Selena had learned at the Alverton was the whole art of the pleasant enemy. The compliment that leaves a bruise.

“Such a great sad house for a little girl.”

Regina Vosper sighed, stroking Winnie’s fair hair while the child stared at nothing.

“So very quiet. A child wants laughter, does she not? And other children, and a mother’s own tenderness.”

“Not…”

A soft glance at the Duke standing by the cold hearth.

“Not a great man’s occasional notice, however kindly meant. Men cannot help it. A little girl slips through the cracks. No one blames you, Your Grace. It is only nature.”

“She does not slip through any crack in this house,” the Duke said.

“Of course not.”

Regina smiled.

“Of course not. I meant no reproach. Only she is all I have left of my sister. You understand? We were so close.”

Her voice trembled, and Selena, watching from her corner with her mending, could not tell how much of the trembling was true. That was the horror of her. Some of it was true. That was what made her dangerous.

“And I have a comfortable home. Time and a woman’s heart and no great name to protect. Nothing to mind but her. Surely, surely a court would see that a mother’s sister who wants nothing but to love her is a fitter guardian than…”

She stopped delicately. She let the room finish the sentence, as Scarrow had, as the whole world did to Selena every day of her life. Selena set a stitch and did not look up and hated her quietly and completely. Later, when Regina Vosper had gone, and Winnie had been carried up to Bessie, shaking and silent, Selena heard the two servants talking in the passage. Low, the way everyone talked in that house.

“She wants the money,” Mrs. Kemp said. “That’s the meat of it. Whatever she cries, the child came into her mother’s portion. And there’s more from the father’s side, all in trust. And the guardian holds the purse till the girl’s of age. Mrs. Vosper’s man died and left her genteel and poor. She wants the girl’s money. Mark me.”

“His Grace holds that trust and never touches a farthing of it,” Pardo said hard. “The child’s fortune grows and his own thins paying for the keeping of it. I have seen the books. He is the honestest man in England and they will hang him for a thief in the public mouth because he will not open his own to defend himself.”

“And why won’t he?” Mrs. Kemp said. “That’s what I cannot fathom. He has only to tell the truth of the bad winter and the whole slander falls. Why does he let them?”

“Because of the child,” Pardo said, and dropped his voice so low that Selena, frozen in the dark of the passage, barely caught it.

“Because the truth of the bad winter is a truth he would rather be hanged than let that little girl grow up knowing.”

“Now hush! Walls have ears in this house. They always have.”

Selena went to her room and sat a long time by her one candle, turning her mother’s thimble on her finger, thinking a truth he would rather be hanged than let the child know. She thought of him in the library with the miniature turned face down. She thought of Bessie’s shaking hand. He is letting them call him the worst, and he has his reasons, and they are good ones. And she thought with a slow, cold certainty that a man could be destroyed by such a silence.