He took a breath.
“Miss Hill was with me all afternoon, every minute. 30 people saw her at my side. She never went near the music room.”
He turned to the little maid in the white cap. She was shaking.
“Tell them, Bessie.”
“Please, sir,” the maid said to the magistrate. “I was dusting in the music room. I saw the young lady in lilac go to the case. I saw her take the brooch and put it in her glove. Then she went out to the garden to the bench with the sewing bag.”
Everyone looked at Blanche. Blanche was wearing lilac yesterday. Everyone had seen it.
“She is lying,” Blanche cried. “Mama, tell them.”
But Mrs. Hill had gone very quiet because the duke was not finished.
“And there is one thing m-more,” he said. “When I knew what kind of woman you were, I asked Mr. Lane to come. He was Dr. Hill’s lawyer. He has b-brought something.”
Mr. Lane opened his leather case. He took out a long paper.
“This is Dr. Hill’s true will,” he said to the magistrate. “I wrote it myself. The house and the money go to his daughter, Louisa, and to no one else. After he died, Mrs. Hill showed me a different will, a newer one, she said. I was not sure of it, but I was an old man and she wept a great deal. Last night, His Grace showed me a letter Dr. Hill wrote to him years ago. The handwriting on Mrs. Hill’s will is not the same. It is not even close.”
The lane was so quiet that Louisa could hear a bird singing in the hedge. Mr. Pike, the magistrate, cleared his throat.
“Mrs. Hill,” he said, “Miss Blanche, I think you had both better get dressed. You will need to come with me.”
Mrs. Hill’s face crumpled. Blanche began to cry loudly. The neighbors in the lane watched them go inside, and not one of them looked sorry. The Duke came up the stairs himself. Mr. Lane had the key. When the door opened, Louisa stood there in her old brown dress with her hands pressed to her mouth.
“I am s-sorry,” the Duke said, “for yesterday, for my silence.”
“You came back,” she said. “You spoke in front of everyone. I know what that cost you.”
“It cost n-nothing,” he said, “not next to you.”
He held out his hand. She took it.
“This is your house now,” he said, “your f-father’s house. You can stay here and be free and never see me again if you wish.”
He stopped. His jaw worked.
“Or…”
“Or?” she said gently.
She waited. She did not hurry him.
“Or you could c-come to dinner,” he said. “Every night for the rest of our lives, I will always pull out your ch-chair.”
Louisa laughed and cried and laughed again.
“Yes,” she said. “Yes, Auberon, and you do not need to say anything else at all.”
But he did. He said her name slowly and perfectly without one stammer, and then he kissed her.