He did not sleep. He had not expected to. He sat the whole of that night in the cold library at Fosscliff with a single candle and an untouched decanter, and he did the thing he had not truly done in 11 years, which was to look without armor at his own life and take an honest accounting of it. He had called himself wise. He saw now that he had only been afraid.
Every cold gray door he had shut, every kindness he had refused, every year he had spent making himself unreachable. He had told himself it was strength, the hard-won prudence of a man who had been deceived and would not be deceived again. But it had not been strength. A woman had shown him that in a fortnight, without meaning to, simply by moving through his house and his land and his life as though people were to be trusted until they proved otherwise, and by being, in every case, herself. Sidwell Glanville was braver with nothing than he had ever been with everything.
She had stood in the wreck of her own good name and reasoned like a general. She had faced down Araminta Vane with sunshine. She had touched his ruined face on a beach and named his cowardice mercy and called it a wound and not a wickedness. And he had rewarded her in the end with the very silence that had made him the hollow man she had first laughed at.
She had been right about that, too. He was lonely. He had built the loneliness stone by stone and called it a fortress. And last night he had watched the only warmth ever to enter it walk out the door and had let it go because he was still, under all the years and all the gray, the same seven and twenty boy flinching from a letter he had read once and never stopped reading.
He thought, as the candle burned down, of all the small evidences he had refused to read for what they were. The account books in her sloping hand, the way his servants had begun to sing, the old widower Halloran sitting straighter in his door. His grandmother laughing again after 11 silent years, his own face in the glass of a morning which he had caught twice or three times lately, wearing an expression he did not recognize because he had not worn it since he was young, the look of a man who has something to get up for. Sidwell had done all of that quietly in a month, asking nothing, expecting to be turned out at the end of the season with exactly what she had brought. And he had let her believe he would let her go because letting her go was written in his own careful hand on the terms of a bargain he had drawn to make her trust him, and he had not had the courage to tear the bargain up and stand before her with nothing between them but the truth.
He saw, in the gray light, precisely what a coward looked like. It looked like a very tidy, very honorable man alone in a cold library at dawn, having reasoned his way clean past the one thing worth having. He was done, he decided as the candle guttered and the first gray came up over the sea. He was done being afraid, and he was done being cautious, and he was done, above all, letting a promise he had made to protect her stand as the excuse that kept him from the only thing that could.