That evening, Vivian sat with Arthur in the library and told him, word for word, what Lady Grosmont had said. Arthur was quiet for a moment, the kind of quiet that means something is being turned over carefully.
“I knew he had a temper,” he said finally. “I had heard it called difficult. I did not know it was called understood.”
“He has been doing this for years,” said Vivian, “to people who had no duke to come down a corridor for them. I had your name and 40 guests, and I still stood against that wall alone for 20 minutes. What happens to the ones who have nothing but their own word?”
Arthur looked at her steadily.
“Then we find out,” he said, “all of it. Not drawing-room gossip, actual accounts, actual people.”
They began, at Vivian’s insistence, with the servants. Mrs. Aldridge, the Hartwell housekeeper, required only the question asked once and asked sincerely. She had the name the following morning.
“There is a woman you should know about, Your Grace,” she said, appearing at the breakfast room door with a look of someone who had been waiting for permission to say something for rather a long time. “A Mrs. Sutton. She worked as housekeeper at Fenn’s own property in Hertfordshire for 6 years. Left without a character 3 years past. She would never say why. She has been in reduced circumstances since. Working as a laundress in Brampton when I last heard.”
Vivian drove to Brampton herself. Mrs. Sutton answered the door of a narrow rented room and looked at the Duchess of Lorne standing on her step with an expression of complete bewilderment, as if she had opened the door expecting the landlord and found the wrong century instead. It took 20 minutes of quiet conversation before she would sit down. It took another 10 before she would speak.
“He came back from London in a black mood,” Mrs. Sutton said at last, her hands flat on her knees. “One of the kitchen girls had set the wrong wine at his place for supper. I had missed it. That was my fault. I’ll own it, but he did not take it up with the kitchen girl.”
She paused.
“He found me in the linen room. He struck me here.”
She touched her left cheekbone twice with an open hand.
“Then he dismissed me on the spot for incompetence, told me I would have no character from him because I’d shown none myself.”
She looked at the floor.
“I’d been there 6 years. I had 30 pounds saved. I spent it in the first 4 months looking for another post without a reference. Nobody takes you without a reference.”
Her hands had not moved.
“I was not the first, Your Grace. I heard from the cook afterward that there had been a parlor maid 2 years before me, a footman before her. I do not know their names.”
Vivian drove back to Hartwell House with a name, a bruised cheekbone 3 years healed, and something that had been anger when she left and was considerably colder by the time she arrived.
