Then one night, very late, she could not sleep. The child was restless. She went down to the dark library, where there was always a fire in the evening, to sit and warm her feet.

The Duke was there. He sat in a big chair by the fire in his shirt sleeves with a glass of water and Rory’s ring on the table beside him. She turned to go.

“Stay,” he said. “Sit, please.”

She sat on the edge of the chair across from him. For a long time, neither spoke. The fire crackled.

“Tell me about him,” said the Duke. “About Penhalo, about how he was.”

So she told him about the beach and the broken boat. “Am I dead? Because if I am, you’re a very pretty angel.” The church roof and the village boys and the terrible sea songs. She told him how Rory had made her father laugh when nobody else could. How he had been afraid of nothing except one thing.

“What thing?” asked the Duke.

“You,” said Carrie quietly. “He was afraid you’d be ashamed of him.”

The Duke closed his eyes. He was silent for so long that Carrie thought he might send her away.

“His parents died when he was seven,” he said at last. “I was 21. Suddenly, I was a duke and I had a little boy to raise. I didn’t know how. My own father was a hard man. He never once told me he was proud of me. So, I was hard with Rory, too. I thought that was how you made a boy into a man.”

He opened his eyes and looked into the fire.

“I was always telling him what he did wrong. I never told him what he did right and he ran away from me again and again. The last time he never came back.”

“He loved you,” said Carrie. “He talked about you all the time. He was angry with you, but he loved you. He said you taught him to ride and to shoot and to stand up straight. He said you were the best man he knew and the loneliest.”

The Duke of Dallow put his hand over his eyes. His shoulders shook just once. Carrie did not say anything. She only sat with him in the warm dark until the fire burned low.

After that night, things were different between them. He came to the linen room in the afternoons and sat while she sewed. He asked her about her father and the book she liked and the sea. She found out he had a dry, quiet humor that he hid from everyone. He found out she could make him smile, which nobody had done in years.

When the maids were cruel to her, he spoke to the housekeeper and the dead mice stopped. When Norah Hotry called her a shameless creature on the back stairs, he heard it. And that night, Norah was told she would take her meals in her own rooms. He still did not say he believed her, but he did not send her away.

And Carrie, who had not expected to feel anything for any man ever again, found herself listening for his step in the hall. She told herself it was only gratitude. She told herself he was Rory’s cousin and a duke and cold as a stone. She told herself many things.


PART 3 — The Letter That Exposed the False Heir – She Hid Her Pregnancy From the Cold Duke — Until He Shut the Library Door and Asked, ‘Whose?’

PART 3 — The Letter That Exposed the False Heir – She Hid Her Pregnancy From the Cold Duke — Until He Shut the Library Door and Asked, ‘Whose?’