He paused.

“Tell him it’s finished.”

Caulfield looked at him through what was clearly considerable pain.

“He won’t accept that,” Caulfield said.

“He will,” Devereaux replied. “When the marshals arrive.”

They left, six horses going south. And then silence, and the Rocking W was quiet again. The cottonwoods along the spring stood still in the windless afternoon. Somewhere overhead a hawk turned wide, unhurried circles, entirely indifferent to the whole business. The marshals rode in on a Friday morning, 3 days after Father Kemp had turned his mule toward the south road, two deputy United States marshals out of Santa Fe, a federal warrant folded in one man’s coat, and a rider Devereaux recognized from his years under Marshal Poe. A man named Garza, who shook Devereaux’s hand in the yard and said without preamble:

“Good timing on the letter.”

The federal warrant named Garrett Pruitt and Sheriff Dale Huck as co-conspirators in a scheme involving bribery of a railroad commissioner, coordinated coercion of private landowners through threatened property destruction, and the corruption of a county law enforcement office for private benefit. Thomas Whitmore’s ledger was the foundation. The bookkeeper’s statement from Tucson was the context. Devereaux’s own testimony was the map that connected everything. Huck was arrested at his desk in Cutter Creek that afternoon.

He didn’t resist. He’d probably known it was coming since the morning at the spring. And there was something in his expression when Garza read the warrant. A faint exhausted easing that suggested some part of him had been waiting for it and was not entirely sorry it had arrived. Pruitt was arrested the following morning at his brick office in Las Cruces.

He came out the front door in a pressed suit, demanding his attorney, and was informed he’d have access to counsel in Santa Fe. He looked smaller than his reputation. That’s what Devereaux always remembered about him later: how small the men who cast the largest shadows always seemed when you finally placed them in ordinary daylight. Huck was stripped of his badge and transported to Albuquerque to await trial.

Consolidated Grazing’s land claims in Haskell County were frozen pending federal investigation, a process that took 2 years to complete, but ultimately resulted in the return of three forcibly acquired properties to their original owners. Garrett Pruitt served 18 months in federal prison and died without money at 61 in an Albuquerque boarding house, which is, as a general matter, where men like Garrett Pruitt tend to end up, friend. The fortune never outlasts the consequences. Father Donald Kemp testified for the prosecution and received clemency in exchange. He resigned his church in Cutter Creek before the trial began, on his own initiative, before anyone asked him to, and no one who’d known him during the Pruitt years offered much in the way of objection.

He moved to a small mission outside Taos and spent the decade that followed teaching children to read, which, when you take the full measure of a person’s life, is not the worst way to spend the remaining portion of it. Cal Devereaux stayed at the Rocking W for 10 days after the marshals came. Long enough to confirm the property was secure.