It was on one of those evenings with the fire gone to embers that the Duke set down his pen and didn’t pick it up again.

“I am going to tell you something I haven’t said aloud to another person in 17 years,” he said. “You may stop me if you would rather not carry it. Nothing between us changes if you do.”

Marianne set down the ledger.

“I would rather you told me.”

“I did not always speak the way I speak now. I did not always require a room to expect the worst of me before I gave them the satisfaction.”

He was looking at the fire, not at her. His voice had gone very level, very controlled. The voice of a man handling something that would shatter if he gripped it wrong.

“At Harrow, when I was 14, I was made to sing before the whole school. A master insisted for a prize I didn’t want and had not asked to compete for. I sang badly. My voice had not yet broken, and it cracked twice in the second verse. Three hundred boys laughed until the master himself had to call for quiet. I did not sing again. I did not laugh easily again either, not for a long while. When I finally did learn to laugh, it came out closer to contempt. Contempt, I had discovered, could not be laughed at in return.”

He turned to look at her, amber eyes very steady in the low light.

“I called you a crow because a crow was the cruelest word I had. I reached for it before I had decided who I meant to hurt with it. You or the boy who had once stood where you stood. The boy who had been laughed at for the same failure of nerve. I have carried that shame for 17 years and told no one. The telling required admitting I had once been the frightened thing I now specialize in frightening others away from becoming. I am telling you now. I am not asking you to forgive it. I want you to know what you may do with the knowledge. Nothing. Everything. Or simply set it down and walk away from this arrangement entirely. Nothing I have offered you is withdrawn if you choose the last of those. You owe me nothing for the telling.”

Marianne sat very still. The fire cracked once low. Neither of them moved toward it.

“You built an entire reputation,” she said slowly, “out of a 14-year-old boy’s cracked voice.”

“I built an entire reputation out of never again standing where I could be laughed at for wanting something in front of an audience.”

His mouth moved, not quite a smile.

“You are an unwitting reminder of a room I have spent 17 years refusing to reenter. I am sorry for what that cost you. I am not sorry I am telling you now, whatever it costs me.”

She did not offer comfort. Comfort was not what the moment asked of her, and she had learned long ago that the wrong kindness could wound as precisely as cruelty. She offered instead the plain fact she had been withholding since the card table at Lady Prowitt, because it was, she understood now, the truer gift.

“I have never once in five weeks heard you raise your voice to anyone in this household who could not raise it back. Fenymore’s daughter did not choose you. You chose to sit with her.”

Something in his face went carefully unguarded for perhaps the length of a single breath. It told her she had understood him correctly. No one had ever told it back to him quite so plainly before.