Twenty minutes later, Evelyn stood across from William at a broad mahogany desk while rain tapped against tall windows. The relief ledger lay open between them. Mr. Bellamy had not appeared; instead, his clerk had sent word that the manager had been called unexpectedly into the village.

William turned another page. “Convenient.”

“Perhaps genuinely.”

“So, you defend him?”

“I distrust conclusions reached before evidence.”

William glanced at her. “Yes, your letter made that painfully clear.”

Evelyn leaned over the ledger. Mrs. Foster’s name appeared twice, exactly as the committee sheet indicated: one entry approved twelve pounds of winter assistance; five days later, another hand had marked the application incomplete.

William placed one finger beside the second entry. “A clerical error.”

Evelyn did not answer. She had noticed something farther down the page: three more widows, two elderly tenants, one injured laborer. Each application had first been approved, then altered. Each bore the same small black mark.

“Evelyn.”

It was the first time he had used her Christian name. She looked up, but his attention was on her face rather than the ledger. Slowly, she turned the book toward him.

“Mrs. Foster is not the mistake.”

William followed the column of altered entries. His expression went still.

Evelyn touched the final figure at the bottom of the page. “Your Grace, someone has been refusing money that your accounts say was already paid.”

William did not move for several seconds. Rain whispered against the windows while the fire settled behind them with a soft crack.

“Paid to whom?” he asked.

Evelyn looked again at the column. “That is the question.”

He pulled the ledger closer. “The estate account shows the full amount withdrawn, but Mrs. Foster received nothing.”

“And neither, presumably, did these others.”

His voice had gone quiet in a way Evelyn suspected made servants more nervous than shouting ever could. She studied the dates.

“Before accusing anyone, we should ask whether the payments were delayed, redirected, or entered incorrectly.”

“You are remarkably determined to protect people you have never met.”

“I am determined not to hang a man with arithmetic until the arithmetic is certain.”

William leaned back. “Remind me never to put you on a jury.”

“Remind me never to commit a crime badly enough to require one.”

The silence that followed was different. William looked at her, and slowly, unwillingly, amusement softened his face.

A knock interrupted them. A footman entered with a tray. “Mrs. Foster has been given refreshment, Your Grace. The steward is checking her documents.”

“Thank you. And Mr. Bellamy?”

“Not yet returned.”

William’s jaw tightened. “Have someone sent to the village.”

When the door closed, Evelyn gathered her papers. “I should return to Bath.”

“No.” She looked up. “That sounded suspiciously like an order.”

“It was badly phrased.”

“Remarkably badly.”

William exhaled through his nose. “Stay until tomorrow.”

Evelyn stared at him. “Your Grace—”

“The roads are worsening, your aunt knows you are here, and I would like your help comparing these applications with the committee records you brought.”

“Those are three separate arguments disguised as one invitation.”

“Will any of them work?”

“The weather might.”

“I shall endeavor to remain grateful to the rain.”

By dinner, a guest room had been prepared for her, and word had spread through Westbridge faster than any official announcement could have managed.

In the drawing room, Lady Caroline regarded Evelyn’s changed gown—a simple dove-gray dress borrowed from one of Aunt Helen’s trunks kept at Westbridge for committee visits—with cool fascination.

“How fortunate that His Grace has found you useful.”

Evelyn adjusted one cuff. “It has always been my ambition to compete with a ledger.”